I know that everyone is going to ask me why isn't Tom Brady on your list?? Well... IMO which is just my opinion so DO NOT tell me I am wrong and don't go all crazy because he's not on my list. I feel that he is a good QB but, I also feel that Rex Grossman is better and that Brady is a bit overrated because of his 3 Superbowl wins. That's exactly what happened with Joe Montana and Dan Marino although I still do feel that Montana was better but, Tom Brady isn't as good as Grossman and this is for current top five QB's I'm assuming so what I feel is that Grossman is better now but, if you were counting last year and all of the years before then Brady is definetly better.
I know that everyone is going to ask me why isn't Tom Brady on your list?? Well... IMO which is just my opinion so DO NOT tell me I am wrong and don't go all crazy because he's not on my list. I feel that he is a good QB but, I also feel that Rex Grossman is better and that Brady is a bit overrated because of his 3 Superbowl wins. That's exactly what happened with Joe Montana and Dan Marino although I still do feel that Montana was better but, Tom Brady isn't as good as Grossman and this is for current top five QB's I'm assuming so what I feel is that Grossman is better now but, if you were counting last year and all of the years before then Brady is definetly better.
heartagram_HIM
If you make such a judgement, one should consider the whole career. There is no way Grossman is better than Brady. We say Emmit Smith or Barry Sanders are better than most running backs because of what they did during their careers, not just 3 games going into the season. And if you can, please explain how Grossman is better than Brady. Keep in mind the Bears' TEAM is playing a bit better than the Patriots but that does not in any shape or form explain that Grossman is better than Brady. I am sure is Brady were on the Bears right now, he would be tearing it up.
I know that everyone is going to ask me why isn't Tom Brady on your list?? Well... IMO which is just my opinion so DO NOT tell me I am wrong and don't go all crazy because he's not on my list. I feel that he is a good QB but, I also feel that Rex Grossman is better and that Brady is a bit overrated because of his 3 Superbowl wins. That's exactly what happened with Joe Montana and Dan Marino although I still do feel that Montana was better but, Tom Brady isn't as good as Grossman and this is for current top five QB's I'm assuming so what I feel is that Grossman is better now but, if you were counting last year and all of the years before then Brady is definetly better.
heartagram_HIM
One notable thing I think you are right about is that you can't say that at this very moment Brady is the best because of his rings. Brady won those championships a few years ago, so they can't be used in a discussion of who is the best right now.
I know that everyone is going to ask me why isn't Tom Brady on your list?? Well... IMO which is just my opinion so DO NOT tell me I am wrong and don't go all crazy because he's not on my list. I feel that he is a good QB but, I also feel that Rex Grossman is better and that Brady is a bit overrated because of his 3 Superbowl wins. That's exactly what happened with Joe Montana and Dan Marino although I still do feel that Montana was better but, Tom Brady isn't as good as Grossman and this is for current top five QB's I'm assuming so what I feel is that Grossman is better now but, if you were counting last year and all of the years before then Brady is definetly better.
wallymartin
One notable thing I think you are right about is that you can't say that at this very moment Brady is the best because of his rings. Brady won those championships a few years ago, so they can't be used in a discussion of who is the best right now.
"Being the best right now" was not specified by the thread creator and since David Carr's passer rating is much higher than Tom Brady's right now, does that mean David Carr is a better quarterback??? Brady not only won those rings but he is smarter and more reliable than Grossman has ever been. I just want someone to explain how Grossman is better than Brady. Carr's passer rating is also better than......................................*gasp* Peyton Manning. Is Carr better than Peyton? I'm sorry, I need Grossman to prove it more than just 3 regular season games to be compared to Tom Brady at this point.
[QUOTE="Goliath_unit"]1. Peyton Manning 2. Tom Brady 3. Carson Palmer 4. Matt Hasselbeck 5. Donovan McNabb (Can't think of anyone else) How is Mcnabb 5th Mcnabb is actually playing the best football out of any quarterback in league rite now.
[QUOTE="bulett6990"][QUOTE="Goliath_unit"]1. Peyton Manning 2. Tom Brady 3. Carson Palmer 4. Matt Hasselbeck 5. Donovan McNabb (Can't think of anyone else) How is Mcnabb 5th Mcnabb is actually playing the best football out of any quarterback in league rite now. True. I know for a fact that McNabb is better than Palmer and Hasselbeck. McNabb is one of the most trusted and reliable quarterbacks in the league.
[QUOTE="Lightening411"][QUOTE="bulett6990"][QUOTE="Goliath_unit"]1. Peyton Manning 2. Tom Brady 3. Carson Palmer 4. Matt Hasselbeck 5. Donovan McNabb (Can't think of anyone else) How is Mcnabb 5th Mcnabb is actually playing the best football out of any quarterback in league rite now. True. I know for a fact that McNabb is better than Palmer and Hasselbeck. McNabb is one of the most trusted and reliable quarterbacks in the league. its MY opinon, i dun care wut u guys say. i chose him to be fifth, u can choose alex smith to be on the list too or having peyton manning all the way at 5, i dun care!
I know most will disagree with Pennington, but to have the Jets as a top team in the AFC East when they were picked to only win six games really proves what he means to them. If he can stay healthy, I feel he will be a top quarterback this season. His last full season before he got the injury bug was great and it seems as though he has picked it up again this season
Log in to comment