Not as bad as everybody is saying
Graphics - Muddy at times but never distracting, its the girl next door not the model. Seriously not that bad though.
Sound - Fitting as far as guns and effects go. The voice acting is a little blah.
Story - Intriguing at first but drags out in the middle a little, I'll say I didn't know the end was the end though.
Playability - Pick up and go if you've ever played a first person shooter.
Fun factor - I'd play it again I really would, I think this game caught some undeserved flak. The multiplayer isn't as good as some other games of the same genre but its not bad.
Replay value - Unlockable content and higher difficulties are some of the things it has to offer, Id play again.
Value - For $40 its not bad, $60 might be a little too steep seeing as theres a slew of games in this genre which are better.
Overall value - Don't buy the negative hype, try it yourself. Rent it like I did and see how well it fits you, If you absolutely hate it like some say they do, at least you didn't fork over $60.