Bioshock Infinite by far..... Last of us is a good game, nice graphics, gameplay, history but.... Bioshock Infinite takes video games to an art form more deep and complex
So, if The Last of Us beat out GTAV on PS3 and GTAV was GOTY on X360, wouldn't the logical choice for overall GOTY be TLOU? Maybe, the other platforms but not sure they would beat either of these games. At the minimum, between PS3 and 360, TLOU is on top.
And again 7 of these 10 nominated games were best on PC...
Should be one of the three remaining: TLOU, GTA V or Ni No Kuni... ;)
Ni no kuni and the last of us, the others dont belong here, and for me it was a tie between those 2, amazing games both of them
Pretty sure game of the year should have went to tomb raider, the last of us or Bioshock infinite. ACIV: Black flag wasn't even out that long..
The only one which should be a 9 is Bioshock the rest should be miles lower and GTA5 is going to biased and high.
Maybe the more hardest decision of my life, well after choosing a nickname in a game or a starter in pokemon
Oh wait, I thought The Last of Us already got the Game of the year.. Hmm any way my favorite was assassin's creed 4: black Flag, as it was the first game in the franchise that I actually enjoyed!
Why are these multiplatform games? I think they should be exclusives. And why is the last of us only an 8? Honestly not a good way to find the "GOTY" for the PS3 when the games aren't exclusive.
The Last of Us has New Game +. And even if it didn't, you're stupid if you don't think it deserves a second playthrough.
How is The Last of Us only an 8? I get that Gamespot is one of the pickiest critics ever to touch the internet, but come on! That game was a masterpiece!
GTA V. The amount of detail they put into that game is insane... It has subtle things throughout its game that PURE games of that genre do not even include(the cars for example, if your hood falls off, you can drive over it and launch it into the air, or another car, or a person.. And the safety devices on the offramps of freeways actually work as they do in real life... and both of those things are completely ignored in PURE racing games. ... and those are just 2 examples.)
Nearly all of these games were multiplatform games, so how could they be Game of the Year on PS3 Nominees? I think they should do exclusives instead. Same with Xbox.
The game play mechanics, sound, visuals, and atmosphere that Naughty dog created was far more deserving of the award than GTAV. Loved GTAV, fun as hell, and a truly amazing amount of detail.. but the Last of Us truly did something amazing.
Last of us if not another attempt to get fuel for a new feedbackula episode..which I wouldn't mind if your new site wasn't so god awfully bad it actually makes me WANT to read IGN.
I would love to see a GOTY for Tomb Raider and The Last of Us. Both were great games. The Last of Us had an amazing story, though I personally felt like the gameplay mechanics could have been done a little better. I've also heard amazing things about the multiplayer, but I was only able to rent the singleplayer of the game, so I haven't been able to play that yet. Tomb Raider lacked in its story while doing an outstanding job with its gameplay. Seriously had a ton of fun with that game and getting the collectibles. Wish I hadn't just rented it. (Though I've heard the Tomb Raider story was really good from some people, when I played it I felt as though the story was difficult to follow). Rayman Legends is also a really fun game, but I don't think it warrants enough to get a GOTY edition. On the same note, Grand Theft Auto V, though an amazing game, is lacking for me. I can understand the hype for it, but I feel like some of these other games deserve GOTY more than GTAV.