Discussion

0 comments
Somajan
Somajan

Good research, but I'm not too fond of your tone. It sounds a little condescending.

kohle36
kohle36

Nothing like an innocuous historical look at architecture to get everyone riled up...

chechak7
chechak7

tee party ,FreeMasoniC ,green dragon join or die

Getbacktogaming
Getbacktogaming

It's just amazing how videogames can immerse you in settings you could otherwise never experiment!

oldschoolvandal
oldschoolvandal

Great piece.

Don't know enough of American history to discuss the game setting but it is nice to see that some of it is based on true locations just like previous games.

 

On a side note....Brazil subways are absolutely not like that...why would they mess the part where they could easily check on line? Not so great fact check Ubi.

Machdoem
Machdoem

hmm FreeMasoniC Lodge eyy spot on Kevin very good. You and Tom McShea are my 2 favourite GS editor. Kevin i hope you will give Black Opt 2 a solid 5.0 lol.

noir45
noir45

what system is this video on?

 

toderascu23
toderascu23

All I can think while watching AC III is that I really really really hate his hair. The hood was much better.

chkmode
chkmode

Well done Kevin. That sure was a historical treat :)

Tacoholic23
Tacoholic23

So much assassins creed 3 articles in the pc section. advertise much lately?..

iomor27
iomor27

Very cool video! As a big fan of history, it's cool to see how accurate the games are that portrays it.

downloadthefile
downloadthefile

The setting is a bit more modern than I'd like; I like a Middle Ages setting much better.

laxstar89
laxstar89

Too bad there would be no way that Achilles would be an African American, it was the first thing I immediately faulted the game; because back then he would have been a slave as unfortunate as that is, and even if he some how wasn't there is no way he would possess land such as that. 

 

I also did not appreciate the blatant attack against America, with the rhetoric of Native Americans, African Americans VS. Whites, Really? i been sick of reading and hearing all about that throughout my years of schooling.  It pains me to see that games of today are so Anti American,  I see the same with the call of duty franchise, It infuriates me because as a service member these people have no idea what war is like... I'm sure the people that had written that game would have loved to see NYC decimated like that by a foreign power, and then to Kill all of the American protagonists at the end, yeah real patriotic. 

 

Assassins Creed 3 would have been way better if it had the same memento from the patriot.  They could have used a member of "Rodger's Rangers" (the beginning of the U.S Army Rangers)  they had fought during the French-Indian war on the side of the british, they were the first unconventional guerrilla force.  It would have been a more acceptable, and more believable root for the main character to follow. 

 

One of the things that I loved about the series of Assassins Creed series was that i felt like i was helping make history as I was playing the game. The other games were so on point with history and events, but AC3 just dropped the ball to conform to the politically correct society that we have, and the blatant Anti American undertones of virtually every title there. 

 

Sorry America is the most badass country ever.

dafrogg
dafrogg

Thanks for this Kevin it was intresting and different.

FuriousHamst3r
FuriousHamst3r

What a treat! Thank you Kevin! Much appreciated!

jyku
jyku

Well I would get this game when it pops up on PC just because I am a fan of the AC franchise however I really felt dissapointed When I first saw That it was placed in the USA dont get me wrong I got nothing against anyone here.... I Was just hopping that they wouldnt AMERICANAIZSE this tittle as well .Someone mentioned for instance

that the US buildings of that time cant be compared with the experience of climbing landmarks as awesome as the prev games, this for me is one huge reason not to place this game in that time period , another would be that It had beeen done so much most ppl are already sick and tired  of the same old Indian(native American) VS THE WHITE MAN stuff,  anyway I ll play the game but I dont xpect much .

 

HERE*S AN IDEEA for the next AC I would personally LOVE , I ve noticed that on the UBISoFT team there plenty of my fellow compatriots , (Romanians -UBI Bucharest guys ) YOU could convice the CEO to place the game WHY NOT durring the Vlad Tepes era( AKA VLAD the Impaler ) and so uncover for everyone the reality It would be cool to see How at that point in Time the Romanian provinces kept Europe safe and Sound from the Otoman Invasion( other major Characters would be welcomed as well Mihail The Brave , Stefan The Great etc etc etc )  , and besides It would be something refreshing a part of a verry rich and Blooody , Sad , Remarcable history ,We Romanians have , and that most ppl dont know about and I am quite sure would love to  hear somthing of it  .Anyway just an Ideea .

CRAPCOM1926
CRAPCOM1926

Worst AC in the series ( Not counting handled consoles)

Kain0067
Kain0067

Thank you for this fantastic video, Kevin. I am all about blending video games and educational history. In fact, as a teacher I've been trying to do just that. I've been pioneering using Minecraft to create virtual, online game learning environments for students. Here's my video from a while back (outdated - the world has been live for some time now and is far more successful than I could have hoped):

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9y6zwv5MZpo

 

Also, here's where I was featured in Time!

http://techland.time.com/2012/09/21/minecraftedu-teaches-students-through-virtual-world-building/

 

Here's to hoping the future holds an even-better blending of actual fun and education!

 

jonasas2
jonasas2

its strange to find a video this serious in gamespot, i mean no racist jokes, the voice was intonation was informative. Kevin should read audio books or use his voice for historicaly based movie trailers

Talisac
Talisac

JESUS, the Brazilian dude is a Nationalist. I live in Brazil, and our streets, specially THE FREAKING SUBWAY, are garbage littered if compared to other countries. Ok, it's not like Blade Runner dirty and all fucked up, but it's most definitely isn't clean. Anyone wants a sincere look, watch Anthony Bordain's episode in São Paulo, he went only to traditional places (which in this case means, not so well-taken-care-of areas of the city), but it'll give you a good idea. And it's true my city does looks like "LA threw up on top of New York" (Bordain said that)... My people are so touchy about getting misrepresented, maybe we should stop making every damn movie and international ads focused on the same stupid crap. The world thinks Brazil is only, soccer, big butts, naked women and ultra-violent "favelas"(slums), well it's not, but I don't blame foreigners because that IS the image we have been selling for fucking decades... When someone says California, you don't automatic think of sunny beaches, that's because the state of California knew how to sell it's image, you know what I mean?

KorhalKk
KorhalKk

Nice of Gamespot listen to brazilian players. I live in São Paulo and take the "Metrô" everyday. Unfortunately it isn't alike in the game. I wonder why ...

SythisTaru
SythisTaru

Any game that encourages people to read more about history is automatically winning. 

Kevin-V
Kevin-V moderator staff

 @Somajan Condescending? Gosh. My Pennsylvania accent and tenor voice may not be everyone's cup of tea, but absolutely no condescension meant within!

Machdoem
Machdoem

 @laxstar89 

Boddy you had to understand first that every major games that create always containing predictive and subliminal messages. Assassin Creed is a game which heavily influence by the occult and symbolism and its motivation are sometime to send the wrong messages or maybe brainwash the young generation. 

 

If you had play all of the pass Assassin Creed you will always stumble a symbol like pyramid with the eye just like what you see in the back of one usa dollar. If you study and analyst it carefully you will see that the pyramid and the eye had the strong relation with the Egyptian pagan god "Horus and AmenRa".

 

They will never stop creating such a game i will give you an example. If you watch a movie called "The Knowing" which release on 2009 in one of the seen it shows you there is going to be an oil spill which destyoy powerplant. One year later you will see how BP Oil spill is taking place and 2 years later Japan power plant leak due to the tsunami. If you look closely you can even see the actor looking at the numbers and focus the camera on the 3/11/... here the link if want to see for yourself.

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=svzInEcDkJ0

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2DrMFyP5YPc

For these link fast forward if you want to cut the long talk and stop it at 3:46 and you will see japan and a letter "M/March".

chkmode
chkmode

 @laxstar89  dude you should look what America has done to other countries in last 5 decades in name of freedom etc. Secondly thats the problem the games/movies are so stereotype. I am a Muslim and what they show is that we all are terrorists ready to bomb ourselves and yet nobody ask them any question.

I do not agree with you that these games are anti American. There are always two sides of a coin so you should also see the other.

I do not know much about  the USA freedom war so cant debate on that.

Devin-B
Devin-B

 @laxstar89 I'm not too sure about what you said about Achilles.  Keep in mind that this was during the late 1700's and slavery was much less prevalent than later years.  In addition, Achilles was in the New England colonies where slavery wasn't much of an issue.  If anything, he would have probably been an indentured servant.  Also, blacks could own land back then and some did.  I'm not saying that what you said is impossible, i'm just trying to put my history degree to good use.

streamline
streamline

 @laxstar89  Achilles could've joined the Assassins many decades ago and/or an Assassin could've bought Achilles because he had great potential and buying him was the only way to free him.

downloadthefile
downloadthefile

 @laxstar89 Anti-Americanism towards the American Revolution is actually quite understandable based on the history.  But every action taken back then had a reprehensible quality to it, not just those by America, so for anyone to say anything too positive or negative about America back in the 1700s really doesn't know the rest of world history.

 

America being the most badass country doesn't make it above criticism, nor does it mean that it's even 1/100th as good as it should be right now.

wasakawaka
wasakawaka

I'd like to see an AC during ww2 when Canada saved the world from the nazis/templars. ;)

heroesfan261
heroesfan261

 @jyku "Someone mentioned for instance that the US buildings of that time cant be compared with the experience of climbing landmarks as awesome as the prev games" that's false, you've never seen the Old North Church. "so much most ppl are already sick and tired  of the same old Indian(native American) VS THE WHITE MAN stuff" except that's what happened. That's history. Americans screwed over the Native Americans, it's a historical fact. They already featured shit with Vlad Tepes in Revelations.

Kevin-V
Kevin-V moderator staff

 @jonasas2 Oh God, I hate my voice. I don't think anyone wants to listen to me talk for extended periods of time!

KorhalKk
KorhalKk

 @Talisac "We" ? Nope, most of us. São Paulo is diverse. There are places beautiful as any New York street, and places ugly as african slum. There IS NO LITTER in the metroviary system. Its overcrowded, sure, but its clean. Ironically one of the cleanest place in the city. For real, I don't believe if you really live here dude.

MarcioHuser
MarcioHuser

 @Talisac you haven't seen the gameplay. I didn't say to Kevin that there's no garbage, I said that in the game there is TOO MUCH gabage. And there's no street, its just subway and straight into the stadium. And at least in Rio the subway is not as trashed as depicted in the game :P

Talisac
Talisac

 @SythisTaru As long as it's not the game's universe history... (looking pissed at 90% of game franchises including Assassin's Creed)

Somajan
Somajan

@Kevin-V the flow of your speech didn't feel very welcoming. Too many pauses and them being in the wrong spot made it feel as though you were talking down to the audience. Try watching some travel documentaries and emulate their style.

laxstar89
laxstar89

 @downloadthefile I can completely agree with you, I am very disappointed with today's America on many levels.  But none the less I do love my country, and I would bleed for the flag to stay red. 

I can understand a quantifiable amount of friction against the revolution.  America gave birth to plenty of revolutions and regime changes from then to modern times, people follow our example to this day. 

 

I wouldn't necessarily say that America didn't know world history, the founding fathers were some of the best and brightest individuals in the world.

jonasas2
jonasas2

 @Kevin-V ask your friends, i thin they would tell you the opposite of what you are thinking

Talisac
Talisac

 @KorhalKk Yes I do, Higien[opolis, near the Buenos Aires park, which is near Villa Boin, where we have The Fifties, La Villete, Musical Box (the owner is named Alan Cohen),  Both FAAP and Mackenzie are nearby (I went to both), as well as Anglo, etc. I guess that`s enough proof, right? Problem is we spend too much time here we get used to ˜lesser wrongs", that doesn't make them right, RIGHT is absolute clean, the more we let it slide, the wronger it gets. I can`t blame you if you don`t know what I'm gonna say, because you're not obliged to unless you went to law school, but most of our laws were built upon European models, the civil law is strongly focused on Italian civil law, what I`m trying to say is, while part of the system TRIES to be "top notch" (and fails), the other is looking at a ˜live and let live pace that gets us with the likes of Serra, Haddad and Russomano as the only real choices of mayor for instance, no matter who wins, the people doesn`t really win, know what I mean? 

Talisac
Talisac

 @MarcioHuser  @Talisac Oh yeah, and sorry for calling you a nationalist dude, it`s just that most of us act like nationalists at every wrong turn a foreigner takes.

Talisac
Talisac

 @MarcioHuser  @Talisac Holy fuck what do you mean no street? lol Feels more like lack of goodwill to create a believable scenario, I bet it feels "lifeless" like the open world games of old as wel :/ I`m not bashing the game though, I`m still getting it later this year when I finish the other stuff.

endorbr
endorbr

 @buccomatic  @SythisTaru Funny since that's actually the point the Assasins and Templars are always going on about in the AC series.

toderascu23
toderascu23

 @laxstar89  Well. history is known to portray people different than they actually were. That's how legends are born. I am not saying that the founding fathers of your country weren't smart but really? In the world?

KorhalKk
KorhalKk

 @Talisac Yeah, Max Payne 3 had a lot of fidelity with our city, but not enough, sadly. I agree with you that our city is neglected, but São Paulo is diverse. Oscar Freire is kinda dirty, but Augusta is dirty only in the "inferninho" side. Its relative. Anyway our city is very rich in "architeture" to Ubisoft explore. I think its because is just a tiny part of the game, I haven't played yet too.

Talisac
Talisac

 @KorhalKk I disagree with our subway being tidy, HOWEVER, as someone wrote above, the game might indeed have exaggerated the amount of garbage, indeed, it's not as fucked up as the streets above (if you go to Oscar Freire as much as I do, you know how dirty it is, and THAT is an internationally famous shopping area, or so I read somewhere, it`s appalling even the richest area, which is ALSO a tourist "attraction", gets so forgotten by the public administration . I didn't play the game yet, so I wasn`t comparing the game, only the opinion, thus, obviously, language is something irritating if they got it wrong (I dunno if you found one, but GTA IV had some random NPCs talking in a perfect Portuguese, actually cursing me for stealing the car, I was so shcoked to hear it that I actually got beaten down by the NPC as he shouted ˜Eita porra! Caralho mano, me d[á essa merda aí!˜ or something lol), I also heard later that the subway somehow ends directly INTO the stadium in the game? That there are no streets or something? That`s strange, and wrong.

KorhalKk
KorhalKk

 @Talisac  @KorhalKk Surey I know everything you mean and agree in terms, but the subway in the game, not only architeture, tidyness, people and language ( what Kevin did comment about ) is not alike anything we have. It bothers me just a little, but its not accurate for a game which relies heavily in such matters. I'll not discuss politics here, I don't believe is the right place to this, but I can repeat over and over again: Our subway is tidy. I don't see  ANY garbage in the ground or anything alike. I take 3 to 4 subway lines everyday.