I think gow3 was a good choice. But i think battlefield 3 is right next to it. I know single player wasnt anything special but the moments in multiplayer are just down right insane and cannot be matched.
They got it right. Gears 3 one of the best all-around games ever made. I'd take it a step further and give it GOTY
Title well deserved. Ive played all the top games and only gears pulled off both excellent single and multiplayer.