Witcher 2 should take this home. No other game pushed the genre forward like TW2 did this year. Normally It should be an easy victory but unfortunately so many people are just following the hype these days so I guess Skyrim is going to win this one although I do trust PC gamers more than console gamers to choose the best game instead of the most hyped game.
Man, I love so many of these games, but I have to say my order would be... 1. Arkham City (Just a pure rush of adrenaline from beginning to end). 2. Skyrim (Huge game, tonnes of content and replayability). 3. Witcher 3 (Fantastic story and super-cool characters).
i thought bf3 would be here, for the audiovisual and for being the most exiting game, i mean non of the games on the list are focused on the thrills they give, they have other things, like gameplay and story.