These are GameSpot's nominees for the Best Action Adventure Game of 2011.
Batman AC and U3 are tied for me
Batman & Deus Ex
just gears of war 3
saints row of course
either Batman AC, U3, or SR the 3rd
as much as i love batman, i still have to give this one to uncharted
I choose Uncharted 3!
Deus Ex for me. In fact it's my choice for game of the year. The game is too damn good haha.