Braid Review

A moving story, serene visuals, and brilliant puzzles make Braid an adventure that you absolutely should experience.

by

Have you ever wondered how the princess locked away in the castle must feel? Or what's going through the head of the eager hero--the valiant young man who gladly leapt over treacherous pits and onto the heads of dangerous foes--after receiving a cursory kiss on the cheek for risking his hide? The motivations of these archetypical characters are rarely explored, but Braid tries to answer these oft-ignored questions. It serves as the contemplative companion to the typical Mario adventure while embracing the unbridled fun found in the best platformers. Clever gameplay mechanics are the driving force, pushing you toward your inevitable confrontation with the woman you've lost, but it's the engrossing story that cements this as something really special.

Braid is the rare game that will make you rack your brain trying to solve puzzles one minute while challenging you to come to terms with its mature tale the next. The plot is succinctly summarized before you enter the first world: Tim, the hero, has made a mistake that cost him his love; now, he has to rescue his lost princess from an evil monster. The story, told through books before each of the six worlds, chronicles Tim's ruminations on the subjects eating away at him. These could be labeled poetic or sappy--depending on your level of cynicism--but they add powerful context to the running and jumping action that follows.

The story in Braid is far from typical.

Tim's thoughts often drift toward changing the past, which ties in nicely with the time-shifting mechanics you'll be employing throughout the entire adventure. Your standard ability allows you to rewind time with the push of a button. The most basic use of this is simply pushing back time to avoid being killed by an enemy or reattempting a mistimed jump, but it goes much deeper than replaying failed opportunities. However, there are green objects and enemies in the world that are unaffected by your time changing powers. So if you unlock a green door and rewind time, it will remain open. Your ability to control time is used in many unexpected and often brilliant ways, making you use parts of your brain that are rarely tapped during most puzzle games.

Later levels retain this basic mechanic but add unique twists that ensure every world feels completely different. Which time manipulation tool you are given depends on what world you're currently exploring. In the fourth world, you control time simply by walking. Every step forward pushes objects and enemies forward in time, while moving backward takes them into the past with you. Because these levels have enemies and items that move in direct relation to you, they have been meticulously constructed to make navigation possible. In another world, you make a copy of yourself every time you rewind time. Your shadow can jump on enemy heads, pull switches, and unlock doors; you just have to perform the action yourself first. The different solutions built around these powers vary widely, so you have to figure out the extent of your powers before you happen upon the always logical solution. Though the puzzles are formidable, Braid never frustrates.

Each of the first five worlds in Braid has 12 different puzzle pieces to collect. The levels are actually extremely short, so if you wanted, you could run through most of the game in little more than 15 minutes, but you'll have to collect all 60 of the deviously placed pieces if you want to see the poignant conclusion. The entire game should take more than six hours to finish, depending on your puzzle-solving acumen. It may seem unfair to ask you to collect every little piece to see the thrilling ending, but by encouraging you to tackle the most challenging puzzles, the game is ultimately much more rewarding than it would have been otherwise. Though the game only forces you to backtrack during one very early puzzle, it's unlikely that you'll be able to nab every piece the first time you play through the worlds. It is only after mastering your abilities and learning your limitations that you'll be able to conquer the puzzles that seemed impossible your first time through.

Most of the puzzles in Braid emphasize clever thinking over quick reflexes. The actions you're required to pull off should be second nature if you've ever jumped on goomba heads in the past. Braid certainly realizes that its running and jumping encounters feel an awful lot like Super Mario Bros.--there are clever references to the venerable plumber throughout the game. From the dangerous plants coming out of pipes to the flag pole that greets you at the end of every world, there are constant reminders of Braid's progenitor. Like the musings from Tim's books before each level, these homages tie into the overarching story of the wounded hero's subconscious longings.

That key was at the bottom of the pit a moment ago.

The subtle visuals are eye-catching but never distracting. The world looks like it was composed with pastel watercolors, swirling blends that create a very distinct look. The characters themselves--Tim, his enemies, and the princess--stand out prominently against the serene, multilayered backdrop. They're like flat, cardboard cutouts colored by markers. The score is elegant and mild--quiet songs that mirror the deliberate pacing. The music bends with the time, racing forward and backward along with your actions. Braid's presentation is uniformly impressive, and serves to complement the gameplay rather than draw focus away it.

It is impossible to ignore Braid's price point. At 1,200 Microsoft points ($15), it is one of the most expensive games for the Xbox Live Arcade service. But do not let a few extra dollars deter you from an exemplary experience that can rival many full-price, retail games. Braid is worth every penny. The captivating ending sequence, which makes use of your rewind ability in a jaw-dropping new way, provides the exclamation point on this remarkable game, but the adventure is consistently engaging throughout the entire ride. The clever puzzles alone are enough to make this an adventure worth taking. Braid's deep and mesmerizing tale is evergreen: it is outside of and beyond time. It will never get old.

The Good
Expertly designed puzzles that offer a hefty challenge without frustrating
Subtle art design that is beautiful without being distracting
A mature story with a powerful ending
Stirring score that perfectly complements the mood
Pin-point controls that let you focus on using your brain to solve puzzles
The Bad
Costs more than most Xbox Live Arcade games
9.5
Superb
About GameSpot's Reviews
Other Platform Reviews for Braid

About the Author

Discussion

17 comments
Gamer3344
Gamer3344

even though you can feel frustrated at some point the soundtrack of this game makes you feel calm and keep playing :)

ChiefFreeman
ChiefFreeman

This is probably still Tom McShea's best review. Very well done. Buying Braid on PSN's $0.99 SALE now!

offcutter
offcutter

It's almost weird how most gamers do not get this game at all. Try to use your brain that you were born with. Not every game is meant to shove the meaning into your brain, try to think a bit at least. And i don't know how anyone could call it repetitive. If this is repetitive then every FPS game is more repetitive by a factor of a million. 

excalibur365
excalibur365

How a game this dull can get this score is way beyond me!! so shallow, repetitive and aimless wandering too.. I wont take any review seriously from now on and will follow my instintcs.. regards.

Granpire
Granpire

I'm a little curious. I've heard @tommcshea  vocalize before on The Hotspot how games that deserve 10/10 are games that couldn't have been improved in any way.

 

If this is true, then how is it that Braid didn't get a 10? Not to demand the score be changed, but I'm a little confused about this. What flaws, if any, does this game have?

TheDonM
TheDonM

Braid is something special

Zheph
Zheph

 @Granpire I gave this game a 9.5. And then I discovered the secret easter egg alternate engine, and immediately pushed it up to a 10. This un-hinted at ending offers more gameplay to play through and blasts your interpretation of the story. I can not fault this game in any way.

excalibur365
excalibur365

@TheDonM seriously?? maybe soo shallow and special in being THAT dull and repetitive. easily one of the most unexciting and aimless platform puzzle game of the market..

Leboyo56
Leboyo56

@Captain_soomro9 The princess was running away from Tim. In the end, she didn't actually want to be rescued. I don't know the exact reason. The whole game you're thinking she's fleeing from the monsters you come across, when in reality she was fleeing from you because of something you did to her.

Braid More Info

First Release on Aug 06, 2008
  • Xbox 360
  • PC
  • + 3 more
  • Macintosh
  • PlayStation 3
  • Unix/Linux
Travel seven platforming worlds to save a princess, but be wary of the peculiar flow of time in each level.
8.1
Average User RatingOut of 6235 User Ratings
Please Sign In to rate Braid
Developed by:
Number None Inc., Hothead Games
Published by:
Number None Inc., MumboJumbo, Zoo Corporation, Avanquest Software, Ignition Entertainment, Hothead Games
Genres:
2D, Action, Platformer
Content is generally suitable for ages 10 and up. May contain more cartoon, fantasy or mild violence, mild language and/or minimal suggestive themes.
Everyone 10+
All Platforms
Language, Mild Cartoon Violence