[QUOTE="roflcopter317"]

[QUOTE="ferret-gamer"]Since you ignored my previous statement i shall reiterate: You are using subjective ratings as factual evidence. Following that usage i bring up the User scores of halo and half life 2, half life 2 scores noticeably higher than halo does. There i combated your "proof" with an argument that you can not legitimately dismiss without also throwing out your main argument as to why it is the best FPS.ferret-gamer

1) The user reviews are not by proffesional reviewers.

2) Proffesional game reviewers are a trustworthy way, and logical way to find out what is the better game.

2. user reviews are subjective

3. subjective does not equal objective.

4. Your choosing to call professional reviewers "trustworhty" is an subjective opinion. One i do not share.

5. if you wish to present an objective argument, You are in not in a place to discriminate between subjective opinions just because certain ones suit you. That is called underrepresentation bias.

So you are saying we can never tell what game is better, because everything is subjective?

[QUOTE="roflcopter317"]

[QUOTE="xYamatox"]

http://www.gamespot.com/n64/action/goldeneye007/index.html?tag=result%3Btitle%3B1

http://www.gamespot.com/n64/action/perfectdark/index.html?om_act=convert&om_clk=gssimilargames&tag=similargames%3Btitle%3B2

lol

xYamatox

Good job. I see you are able to give me a link to ONE game website which has a higher score then the game I mentioned. Try giving me the score from meta critic, which is CORRECT logic, and see how far you get XD.

Metacritics is just taking a small group of opinions from people who run websites. If you would notice, both links I have given you showns that Gamespot (the ONLY credited website that actually specializes in game reviews) and the actual PLAYERS say both are better than Halo. Just end it now, TC. Just end it now. :)

Meta critic are all the scores from EVERY proper reviewer out there. You failed again.

your so call fact only show that it's more popular then others fps and enjoyed by more people. I fail to see how does that make it look better. It's the best for you and other people, but i would take killzone 2 over any halo any day of the week

da_illest101

And now you can see, that fanboys have been stripped down bare, now the only thing that can resort to is graphics.

I'll repeat .... Instead at looking at reviews how about you see what people are interested in and notice maybe 5 percent of people may agree with you here.....God FANBOYS are great!!!! They always give you a good laugh when needed I love how out of all the replys not one person yet agreed!!!! And he is still going and going......hkymike

I don't even want to reply to this using simple logic... But I will. First of all, read back to what I said:

"because that is incorrect logic. It would be like trying to find out how many people in the world have black hair by going to one certain place, getting 10 people at random, then saying "It looks like there are 2 people with black hair here, that means 20% of people in the world have black hair"."

A few people in one place doesn't = everyone in the world.

Since you ignored my previous statement i shall reiterate: You are using subjective ratings as factual evidence. Following that usage i bring up the User scores of halo and half life 2, half life 2 scores noticeably higher than halo does. There i combated your "proof" with an argument that you can not legitimately dismiss without also throwing out your main argument as to why it is the best FPS.ferret-gamer

1) The user reviews are not by proffesional reviewers.

2) Proffesional game reviewers are a trustworthy way, and logical way to find out what is the better game.

Ohh roflcopter is back lol[QUOTE="_SWAG_"]

i sold every halo game i got when killzone, resistance, uncharted and haze came out. all of them kilt halo imho

johny300

Another opinion? Great. Let me counter act that statement with your pure logic:

NO OMG U R WRONG. HALO IS WAIIII BETTR THEN HAZE!

No...

Crysis is better than every single Halo in every single way except MP.

Edit: And prove you wrong? You need some proof for us first.

Filthybastrd

I can make an opinionated statement too. CRYSIS IS THE WORST GAME EVER MADE IN EVERY WAY POSSIBLE 0/10. See what I did there? I used you illogical way of thinking.

[QUOTE="xYamatox"]

[QUOTE="roflcopter317"]

Halo is the best first person shooter of all time, and here is my evidence: It is the highest scoring fps on meta critic, the most critically aclaimed, and the latest in the series is at least in the top 3 of highest selling fps games of all time (4,049,91 in one week, half life 2 could barely get 4.13 mill in 6 years!).

Highest scoring fps of all time:

http://www.metacritic.com/game/xbox/halo-combat-evolved

One of the highest selling games of all time:

http://gamrreview.vgchartz.com/sales/35024/halo-reach/

Fanboys, go ahead and state your opinions, which you will obviously not back up with facts and etc.

hkymike

http://www.gamespot.com/n64/action/goldeneye007/index.html?tag=result%3Btitle%3B1

lol

I never 'shut up', because that is incorrect logic. It would be like trying to find out how many people in the word have black hair by going to one certain place, getting 10 people at random, then saying "It looks like there are 2 people with black hair here, that means 20% of people in the world have black hair". Derp da derp *facepalm*.

[QUOTE="roflcopter317"]

Halo is the best first person shooter of all time, and here is my evidence: It is the highest scoring fps on meta critic, the most critically aclaimed, and the latest in the series is at least in the top 3 of highest selling fps games of all time (4,049,91 in one week, half life 2 could barely get 4.13 mill in 6 years!).

Highest scoring fps of all time:

http://www.metacritic.com/game/xbox/halo-combat-evolved

One of the highest selling games of all time:

http://gamrreview.vgchartz.com/sales/35024/halo-reach/

Fanboys, go ahead and state your opinions, which you will obviously not back up with facts and etc.

xYamatox

http://www.gamespot.com/n64/action/goldeneye007/index.html?tag=result%3Btitle%3B1

http://www.gamespot.com/n64/action/perfectdark/index.html?om_act=convert&om_clk=gssimilargames&tag=similargames%3Btitle%3B2

lol

Good job. I see you are able to give me a link to ONE game website which has a higher score then the game I mentioned. Try giving me the score from meta critic, which is CORRECT logic, and see how far you get XD.