It's hardly a people choice when 72% picked something else. Basically any non Sony gamer picked a game he enjoyed most, but every Sony owner picked Uncharted. Your voting was rigged by a logical fallacy. In order to make it right you should have run rounds shortening list of games available for vote.
@kyelo: what I am saying is let's not play metacritic scores, where Uncharted has an unfair advantage of being reviewed, as you said yourself, by non gaming outlets, which did give him a few notches in metacritic score above the competition. Being casual, mainstream and selling gazillion of copies doesn't automatically make a better game, or else games such as COD would be GOTYS every year.
Souls Series did sell well, by the way. Over 3M copies.
@kyelo: Yeah, right. Only 5 from Sony magazines... LMAO Then you can explain me how can it be that there 113 reviews for Uncharted 4 and only 70 reviews in total for the most anticipated multiplat Dark Souls 3 ? There are only 52 review for W3: Blood and Wine. There were only 80 reviews in total for Witcher 3. We are talking about multiplatform games that should have much more reviews than PS4 exclusive because they are being multiplatform and all. Where these huge discrepancies between multiplats and Sony exclusives on total amount reviews come from ? The truth is Sony exclusives somehow get the biggest amount of reviews in total than any multiplatform game. And we are not talking about some small difference 5-10 reviews. We are talking about 30 extra reviews for a Sony exclusive such as Uncharted 4. Smells super fishy to me.
@kyelo: Still it's a very shallow and casual game. Even if it's 93 on MC it's not better than Dark Souls (89) and The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt - Blood and Wine (92)
Uncharted score was artificially inflated by Sony magazines and blogs that unanimously gave it 9+ and 10 scores.
If I see Uncharted 4 as number 1, I will never take you seriously Gamespot. You are already grating on my nerves by putting Civilization 6 and Dark Souls 3 so low, you bunch of sellouts. IGN is now more respectable outlet than you are.
@Bowser05: But according to statistics, they do overscore Sony games. These last couple of years, they scored every Sony game higher than IGN, i mean IGN was always generous with their scores, so yeh when you score higher than 9GN i do believe there is certain degree of pro-Sony bias.
jhonMalcovich's comments