Small things like multiplayer maps should be free, always. Updates of that kind are too important to leave them alone, but not important enough to pay for them. If you really like the game you are almost forced to buy that stuff. And that I find inacceptable.

Stuff like additional chapters in campaigns can be charged. They are like small games so it's only natural to buy them. Also I agree with micro-payment stuff like charakter outfits. They are not needed in the game so it's absolutely the customers choice to buy them.

For me it was Borederlands. That is not a bad game by any means, as a matter fact I love it but, I was expecting so much more from it.

doabarrelrole

Indeed. Gameplay-wise it's a great game, but the presentation failed. I was hoping for a wacky humourous plot, not some boring mmorpg-like quest-after-quest trash.

Besides that I'm joining the "Disappointed-in-MGS4"-branch. It just didn't come close to the quality of it's prequels. Especialy the recycled boss fights left me disappointed. The fight with Whatshername Wolf for example just was a trashy version of the duel with The End in MGS3.

Legend of Dragoon - Played through it at least once every year since release.

Hot Shots Golf: Out Of Bounds - There were breaks whenever I was focused on a new game I got, but I've always been playing this since I bought it a year ago.