I was able to add the top pick titles on the 'create list' page to a new list, so I guess it's not completely gone.

http://www.gamespot.com/game-list/

So custom lists are not working, period? Well, bummer.

One thing though, would you share how you got to the custom list functionality? I'd like to give them a step by step process on how they can reproduce the issue.JodyR

I created a new list, then I tried to enter a title.

The only other way is to add to your game collections, based on clicking the plus button near the retail box. That would end up in your game lists on your profile, but as for an actual custom list, that's the broken one is it.JodyR

Yeah, I thought so.

Anyway, is there any other way I can add titles to a custom list except from the list page?

My problem is that the 'title-loader' on the list page never finishes loading any titles I type in it:

http://i50.tinypic.com/2d0gbxg.png

When I try to add a game to my custom game list (by starting to type out a title) it doesn't load any titles (which I assume is what it's supposed to do, this is my first list), it gets stuck loading.

I rated Seiklus,

http://www.gamespot.com/seiklus/platform/pc?tag=result%3Btitle%3B0

the score shows in my ratings but the title is blank.

Like this:
http://i43.tinypic.com/15gc6z9.jpg

They're all working for me now, thanks.