Okay, I've had a 360 from launch and so has my friend.
Unfortunately he has 4 other hardcore fan boy friends who all had the 360 then switched to PS3's. Needless to say they talked my friend into going to the PS3 and I never see him on the 360 anymore. Anyways, I went to his house and he had the 360 and PS3 both hooked to his receiver and then fed through HDMI to his Sony 60" Bravia LCD
So with both copies of COD4 in hand we decided to run some tests. He was convinced before the test that the PS3 was superior. Well, after getting both games to a point when you first start in the hangar and are speaking to Pierce, we switched TV input to go back and forth between the 360 and the PS3. Let's just say we were both surprised. I was expecting a slight edge to the PS3. Not the case. The Sony had muddied , blurred textures, a somewhat washed out look, and even some frame rate issues when zooming. Let's just say he was pissed. He was convinced from a placebo effect that the PS3 was better, his red face now showed otherwise. I just said, well looks like you can come back to the system with better graphics huh...No comment from him
Then I picked up the Sixaxis controller. I was amazed. First off the concave tiny triggers felt not only out of place but like they would snap off if squeezed to hard. Due to the small size, my fingers kept slipping down when I squeezed the triggers. Next I noticed the thumb stick placement, again, they had a very cheap feel and the close proximity of them caused my thumbs to literally bump and conflict with each other as they met up in the middle during certain look/movement/strafe commands. Not good...The placement of the sticks to the triggers was also awkward and did not provide a comfortable feel like the excellent 360 controller. Finally, no rumble support, yuck....no thanks
So he goes back to the interface...what a plain boring, non intuitive mess.
I left telling him thanks, I almost got a PS3 to play UT3 on, but I'll save my money. His words were, yeah, but at least I have Blue Ray...I left telling him to enjoy all those Disney Blue Ray's
360 wins IMHO - superior interface, graphics, and controller
Maybe with the new rumble sixaxis, and HOME and some future developers taking advantage of the PS3's tech, it will shine...for now though, just glad I didn't waste my money
Comparisons or different experiences welcome
Log in to comment