Well I think I get the frustration of everyone over this review! GTA V it's a wonderful game and even though you can't probably give it a 10/10 the reasons why Carolyn gave it a 9 instead of a 10 seemed completely unreasonable and that is why many of you, including my self don't appreciate the review!
First of all she argues that the game is misogynistic when all GTA games are like that, men are not depicted as the 'crown jewels' of the society either and last but not least she didn't complain about that when she game GTA IV a 9.5!
Second you can't lower the score of a game because the "character behavior is sometimes inconsistent"! That doesn't make any sense, since that alone can't possibly affect your experience of the game. I mean even if this does happen in the game it's not that often that you can even consider it as negative...:\
Oh well that is just my opinion, Im not saying the game deserves a 10, there are flaws with it but I don't think these flaws are the ones mentioned by Carolyn...
Ex-Ware's comments