POTC fans will love this game, despite its shortcomings...
There are lots of little nitpicky problems with the game, but they are easy to ignore if you are a fan of the movie and the characters. The controls arent perfect, the enemies are easy to defeat. However, it does have a very good storyline, the voicework of Johnny Depp, and great characters.
I presonally loved the movie and enjoy pirates in general. This is the best pirate related game I've ever played.
I just started playing it and I love it.