Dual Shocked: Sony Immersed in $90.7 million fine, injunction

By Tim Surette, GameSpot
Posted Mar 28, 2005 11:14 am PT

US District Court favors San Jose tech company Immersion; Sony injunction to halt American sales of PS2s and affected materials.

Three years ago, Northern California technology company Immersion Corporation brought a suit against Sony Computer Entertainment and Microsoft Corporation claiming patent infringement of its proprietary technology used in the controllers for the companies' home consoles: the PlayStation, PlayStation 2, and Xbox.

Microsoft settled out of court with Immersion in 2003, avoiding messy legal proceedings for $26 million, which also got Microsoft a 10 percent stake in Immersion.

Sony, on the other hand, left the decision up to the courts, a move that appears to have cost the company a serious chunk of change. Last Thursday, United States District Judge Claudia Wilken ordered the electronics giant to pay Immersion $90.7 million in patent infringement damages. The fine stems from the $82 million awarded to Immersion by a jury's decision on September 21, 2004, plus prejudgement interest of $8.7 million tacked on last week, which Sony unsuccessfully objected to.

The tiff involves Immersion's technology that creates the "rumble" feature that causes controllers to vibrate in sync with events in games. The court found in favor of Immersion's claims that Sony's Dual Shock controllers, the standard sticks for Sony's PlayStation and PlayStation 2, and several of its games infringe on two of its patents.

The Oakland, California, court also ordered an injunction stating that Sony is to immediately stop selling the PlayStation, PlayStation 2, both versions of the Dual Shock controllers, and 47 games found to use the vibration technology, including Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3, Grand Theft Auto: Vice City, and Gran Turismo 3. The injunction only affects sales in the United States.

Sony immediately appealed the decision and has been granted a stay of permanent injunction, allowing Sony to sell its products as normal during the appeals process. However, Sony will have to pay a licensing fee to Immersion for the duration of the stay.

11 Comments

Refresh comments

gun5z
Posted Apr 24, 2008 4:02 pm PT

haha ouch Sony... that would get me...
- Login to rate this comment
SirSmokeal0t
Posted Apr 22, 2008 9:14 am PT

Way to go Sony, now i can go waste another 60 bucks on a supposed 'Dual Shock 3' that's exactly the same as the old Dual Shock. Ugh.
- Login to rate this comment
dooby95286
Posted Apr 19, 2008 5:43 pm PT

wow Microsoft made a smart move settling outside of court.
- Login to rate this comment
Noobberry
Posted Sep 18, 2007 7:41 pm PT

SONY....OWNED
- Login to rate this comment
CT-Link
Posted Jan 11, 2007 9:44 am PT

HAHAHAH Sony got owned, big time! and yes that IS a lot of change...lol
- Login to rate this comment
The_Weekend
Posted Jan 11, 2007 8:02 am PT

SONY got pwned
- Login to rate this comment
damien_hunziker
Posted Jan 11, 2007 5:07 am PT

haha too bad for the US
- Login to rate this comment
EMAN2g
Posted Jan 10, 2007 8:48 pm PT

LOL SONY...LAWLZ
- Login to rate this comment
comthitnuong
Posted Jul 14, 2006 12:45 pm PT

wow.....thats not good
- Login to rate this comment
thisisjosh
Posted May 8, 2006 10:53 pm PT

of course.
- Login to rate this comment
12David12
Posted Apr 18, 2006 5:06 pm PT

so is this the end of playstation? I mean if sony loses this battle the playstation market shuts the doors, so what does this mean for ps3? Will there be a future for playstation?
- Login to rate this comment

Content you might like…

Sony Dual Shock 3 Hands-On
Find out how the Dual Shock 3 compares to the Sixaxis and the Dual Shock 2 in our hands-on report.
- Apr 18, 2008
Judge upholds suit against Sony
Nintendo loses controller case
Anascape sues Microsoft, Nintendo
Nintendo controllers facing possible ban

Users who looked at this article also looked at these content items.

Hot Stories

Newsmakers

TGS 2008: Microsoft's Schappert soldiers on in Japan

Despite the Xbox 360's limited success, corporate VP and Xbox Live chief says sales are increasing in the "very important" market. Full Story
- Posted Oct 9, 2008 10:30 am PT
- 32 Comments
TGS 2008: Is Japan's gaming influence waning?

Executives from Square, Capcom, and Namco Bandai open up about how they feel their country is losing gaming clout--and how they think the Japanese game industry can turn itself around. Full Story
- Posted Oct 9, 2008 12:10 am PT
- 205 Comments

Featured Stories

Fallout 3 finally finished

Time for retailers to duck and cover because development has wrapped on Bethesda's postapocalyptic role-playing game in anticipation of its October 28 debut. Full Story
- Posted Oct 9, 2008 1:01 pm PT
- 351 Comments
Xbox 360 gets bundles of holiday joy

Microsoft adds Sega Superstars Tennis to $199 Arcade boxes, whereas standard $299 and Elite $399 systems will come packed with Lego Indy, Kung Fu Panda. Full Story
- Posted Oct 9, 2008 7:42 pm PT
- 121 Comments
Game stocks bloodied in market meltdown

Activision falls 28%, THQ sheds 39%, EA slides 37%, and Take-Two loses 40% during four-week roller-coaster ride on Wall Street, capped by today's sixth-straight triple-digit Dow Jones drop. Full Story
- Posted Oct 9, 2008 8:33 pm PT
- 224 Comments
TGS 2008: Tekken 6 smacking Xbox 360

Namco Bandai kicks off Tokyo Game Show with confirmation that long-awaited PS3 fighter will launch on rival console simultaneously in fall 2009. Full Story
- Posted Oct 8, 2008 9:00 pm PT
- 997 Comments
TGS 2008: Halo 3: Recon revealed, new Xbox Live due Nov. 19

Xbox Live chief John Schappert talks about Microsoft's Japan strategy; prequel expansion to Bungie's shooter due Fall 2009; avatar-based XBL relaunch coming next month; Tekken 6 confirmed for 360; trailer inside. Full Story
- Posted Oct 8, 2008 8:13 pm PT
- 298 Comments