(SPOILERS)Red Dead Redemption

Was anyone happy with the ending? I was extremely pissed...

Any comments would be cool, just wondering what you thought.

Yea I thought it was kinda lame that you had to play as emo Jack, and I swear I thought the game ended like 3-4 times before it actually did. Although it was kind of cool how John sacrificed himself for his family.

I wasn't that big of a fan of the game asa a whole though.

I thought the ending was a complete letdown, the epilogue mission was crap storywise.

I thought the ending was a complete letdown, the epilogue mission was crap storywise.

andalore

Man I thought the whole game was a letdown. Doing dirty work after dirty work, in practically the same damn format as GTA 4. Not to mention the actual content of the game (dialogue, gameplay, characters) was pretty lame.

I actually enjoyed it. Sweet, sweet revenge.

I actually liked the ending, it showed really braver for john to die the way he did. if he wouldve left, he would realize that ross and his friends would keep looking for him

I just don't get why Ross killed off John. And what did you do to get revenge on his family?

I just don't get why Ross killed off John. And what did you do to get revenge on his family?

rpg_addition

I thought Red Dead Redemption was great. I loved the story. I don't understand why so many people complain about it. The repetitive missions didn't bother me. I mean, what else do you expect from the missions besides running around and killing people? That's what John is meant to do. I focused more on the story than the gameplay.

And all the negative talk about Jack is really frustrating. People don't understand what kind of character he was meant to be and the character he unfortunately becomes in the end of the game, and so they whine about him being weird, annoying, etc. I thought that he was displayed very well throughout the entire game.

[QUOTE="rpg_addition"]

I just don't get why Ross killed off John. And what did you do to get revenge on his family?

Agent-Zero

well in the end what happen is Ross never really planed to let John go in the first place. They used him to do their Job and then killed him. Thats the whole theme of the game if you ask me. You cant just go and live a life of crime and then act like it never happened. people dont forgive stuff like that and deep down inside John knew that. Thats whay they have the "Outlawas to the end" slogan.

So what did you guys do to get revenge? I hogtied his wife and put bait next to her, then a pack of wolves came and killed her. I just shot Ross' brother heaps.

So what did you guys do to get revenge? I hogtied his wife and put bait next to her, then a pack of wolves came and killed her. I just shot Ross' brother heaps.

rpg_addition

Haha,, all I did was fill Ross's face with about 6 rounds from my High Power Pistol....btw I don't get the whole emo Jack thing...How is he emo?

The ending was actually quite good storywise. If I wanted to read into it I would say Marston's death represented the death of the cowboy and the invasion of technology, one of the ongoing theme's in the plot. However, this is not an english class, so let's just say the ending was pretty badass.

Now what I didn't like was having to play as his "girlyman" (as governor schartzenegger would put it) of a son to complete the rest of the game. If he says "work it there nag" one more time, I swear to god I will lose it!

Does Jack remind anyone else of Orlando Bloom in the Pirates movies?CodingGenius

Yes! i think its the goatee/beard combo

i felt like they killed john marston unreasonably, just to give the player a shell shock, it seems really out of character for him to walk into fire like that, i mean after all we spend the whole game realizing how badass marston is, but in the end he goes like a nobody.

Are you guys kidding me? The ending was awesome. I thought it was really heartfelt. You save your family, then you walk out the barn and get lit up. I almost cried!

and playing as Jack is so fitting. The epilogue mission is justified. (Red Dead.... REDEMPTION)

and did you guys notice? Your family is buried on the same hill where you find the "I Know you" quest. Its a connection to god/heaven. Really well done.

I loved the ending.

I thought the ending was brilliant! great way to end the game. idk about you guys but GTA4 was a letdown for me

i felt like they killed john marston unreasonably, just to give the player a shell shock, it seems really out of character for him to walk into fire like that, i mean after all we spend the whole game realizing how badass marston is, but in the end he goes like a nobody.

realblood33

Yeah, I didn't like the Ending. I was like:

Are you guys kidding me? The ending was awesome. I thought it was really heartfelt. You save your family, then you walk out the barn and get lit up. I almost cried!

and playing as Jack is so fitting. The epilogue mission is justified. (Red Dead.... REDEMPTION)

and did you guys notice? Your family is buried on the same hill where you find the "I Know you" quest. Its a connection to god/heaven. Really well done.

I loved the ending.

Shmiity

Yeah, I didn't like the Ending. I was like:

Snipes_2

[QUOTE="andalore"]

I thought the ending was a complete letdown, the epilogue mission was crap storywise.

SilentSoprano

Man I thought the whole game was a letdown. Doing dirty work after dirty work, in practically the same damn format as GTA 4. Not to mention the actual content of the game (dialogue, gameplay, characters) was pretty lame.

i felt like they killed john marston unreasonably, just to give the player a shell shock, it seems really out of character for him to walk into fire like that, i mean after all we spend the whole game realizing how badass marston is, but in the end he goes like a nobody.

realblood33

The reason he did that was because he knew that it would never end, his past would always catch up to him. If he had ran he would be putting his family in danger, his redemption was his death.

It was a cool ending it was just lame playing as jack though XP

didnt like it too much, just didn't feel right.

Are you guys kidding me? The ending was awesome. I thought it was really heartfelt. You save your family, then you walk out the barn and get lit up. I almost cried!

and playing as Jack is so fitting. The epilogue mission is justified. (Red Dead.... REDEMPTION)

and did you guys notice? Your family is buried on the same hill where you find the "I Know you" quest. Its a connection to god/heaven. Really well done.

I loved the ending.

Shmiity

I never understood what the point of that side quest was.

I didn't like that you couldn't play as John after the ending. It means that DLC will also be emo Jack. Does Jack remind anyone else of Orlando Bloom in the Pirates movies?CodingGenius

LMAO!

On topic: the ending could have been much better for sure. I beat the game and thought to myself how am i going to free roam now? EMO JACK!!! meh the game was great but they definately stumbled at the end.

Was anyone happy with the ending? I was extremely pissed...

Any comments would be cool, just wondering what you thought.

rpg_addition

I liked the ending VERY MUCH because it was realistic. There was nor riding off into the sunset with a happy song, there was no lets kill on these officers & then have dinner around the table...the was ONLY you do bad & you get punished for it at the end. One of the most realistic & amazing games I've played this year.