Most Overrated and Underrated X360 Game?

So what do you think, my opinion is

Most Overrated: Call of Duty 3

Most Underrated: Call of Jaurez

Overrated: Forza 2

Underrated: Call of Duty (how the hell is it overrated?)

Overrated: GRAW

Underrated: ???

Overrated: Gears of War 9.6 > 8.8

Underrated: Shadowrun 6.9 > 8.5

Overrated - Rainbow Six Vegas, GRAW, Gears of War

Underrated - Call of Juarez, Shadowrun, Prey, Quake 4, Crackdown, Condemned, Lost Planet, Kameo

Overrated: Halo 3

Underrated:Unreal Tournament 3

Shadowrun, BioShockOwnz

Overrated: PDZ, Kameo

Underrated: Gears of War, R6V, GRAW 2

Over-rated > Halo 3 (it's only another FPS IMO)

Under-rated > Kameo: Elements Of Power

Overrated: PDZ, Kameo

Underrated: Gears of War, R6V, GRAW 2

jimmygrace

You do know what underrated means, right? :|

Overrated: PDZ, Kameo

Underrated: Gears of War, R6V, GRAW 2

jimmygrace

Yeah right!?

Overrated: PDZ, Kameo

Underrated: Gears of War, R6V, GRAW 2

jimmygrace

:|

Overrated: PDZ, Kameo

Underrated: Gears of War, R6V, GRAW 2

jimmygrace

Your name should be jimmy (dis) grace, how is GRAW, GoW & R6V underrated? They all got near perfect scores how can that be underrated?

overrated- GeoW

underrated- Hitman

Overrated-Gears of War (should've been 8.6)

Underrated-Shadowrun

overrated- GeoW

underrated- Hitman

gatsbythepig

[QUOTE="jimmygrace"]

Overrated: PDZ, Kameo

Underrated: Gears of War, R6V, GRAW 2

KingKoop

Your name should be jimmy (dis) grace, how is GRAW, GoW & R6V underrated? They all got near perfect scores how can that be underrated?

No need to be ignorant to the fact that he made a simple mistake "it happens", cant wait till you slip up :evil:

Overated: Gear of War, Halo 3

Underated: Dirt, Shadowrun

[QUOTE="KingKoop"][QUOTE="jimmygrace"]

Overrated: PDZ, Kameo

Underrated: Gears of War, R6V, GRAW 2

sadikovic

Your name should be jimmy (dis) grace, how is GRAW, GoW & R6V underrated? They all got near perfect scores how can that be underrated?

No need to be ignorant to the fact that he made a simple mistake "it happens", cant wait till you slip up :evil:

Whose to say he slipped up? For the record I'm not being ignorant, what gives you justification to say who or what I am?

Overrated = Gears of War (Most overrated game EVER imo)

Underrated = Hmm... Crackdown, LostPlanet, Enchanted Arms, Ninety-Nine Nights, and I'm sure some others, too.

[QUOTE="sadikovic"][QUOTE="KingKoop"][QUOTE="jimmygrace"]

Overrated: PDZ, Kameo

Underrated: Gears of War, R6V, GRAW 2

KingKoop

Your name should be jimmy (dis) grace, how is GRAW, GoW & R6V underrated? They all got near perfect scores how can that be underrated?

No need to be ignorant to the fact that he made a simple mistake "it happens", cant wait till you slip up :evil:

Whose to say he slipped up? For the record I'm not being ignorant, what gives you justification to say who or what I am?

Well you ignore the obviouse fact that he has misplaced his wording, and its either that or he was making a joke and neither would give you the right to call names.

To answer your question I do believe we are online and freedom of speach is in affect so I can pretty much justify you in any manner I please.

Either way you seem to have some arguementative problems and like to pick pointless fights over forums so Im just gonna leave now since you clearly have no care for others but jump to the gun when you are being named for something.

Ignorance and doublestandards are two evil parts of your attitude that I dont want to get in the way of.

overrated: pro evolution soccer 6 (8.1, should have been 5.0 imo)

Underrated: far cry instincts: predator (7.9, should have been 8.8 imo)

Overrated=Gears of war (8.1)

Underrated=Shadowrun (8.5)

Overated: Gears of War

Underrated: Lost Planet

Over rated: Gears of war defanatly hands down. Dont get me wrong it was alot of fun but it got old realy fast.

Under rated: I dont know all the games i like have at least over an 8. But rainbow six I think is way better than Gears.

overrated: even though I love it GeoW 9.0

underrated: Battlefield, such a solid online experience 8.6

overrated- GeoW

underrated- Hitman

gatsbythepig

overrated- GeoW

underrated- Hitman

gatsbythepig

I'm glad you mentioned Hitman as underrated. It is such an amazing game.

Overrated: Gears of War, Call of Duty 3

Underrated: Viva Pinata, Shadowrun

Overrated = Gears of War

Underrated= Shadowrun

Overrated- Gears of War, GRAW

Underrated-Kameo, Enchanted Arms, Viva Pinata, Shadowrun, GUN, The Godfather

Overrated: GRAW 2 and Technu z

Underrated: Shadowrun

overrated/overhyped: GTA IV, probably COD3 just because it was a huge dissapointment when i loved COD2 sooooo much

underrated: Shadowrun, Lost Planet

Overrated-Gears of War (should've been 8.6)

Underrated-Shadowrun

II-FBIsniper-II

how can you call a game overrated when you have practically all the achieements for it

oh and

overrated oblivion

underated shadowrun and marvel ultimate alliance

Over- CoD3

Under-UT3. CoD4, and if it has to be out Shadowrun

Overrated: Halo 3

Underrated:Unreal Tournament 3

Vance_009

Exactly my thoughts. Halo can't hold a candle to UT. console fps will always be inferior to pc shooters.

CS + UT > Halo + GEoW + PDZ + Shadowrun combined.

overrated - OBLIVION ...mehhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

Underrated- Hitman ... meeep meep

Overrated: Gears of War

Underrated: Spider-Man 3

Overrated- Rainbow Six Vegas

Underrated- Call of Juarez (AWESOME GAME)

overrated - halo 3 will be and any racing besides burnout

underrated -definitely shadowrun

Over-rated > Halo 3 (it's only another FPS IMO)

Under-rated > Kameo: Elements Of Power

KingKoop

How in the world can a game be overrated if it isn't even out yet.
It doesn't even have a rating!

Overrated = Gears of War

Underrated = Call of Juarez

Overrated= Gears of War (IMO since the first patch when they took the host name off of ranked rooms, and the new glitches)

Also Overrated= Halo 3 beta (especially to a person who's new to Halo games. i know its technically not a game, but hey!)

Underrated= Shadowrun, Enchanted Arms, and God Father

overreated PDZ it was rubbish

underrated Prey that game was a laugh ...

Besides Gamespot's rating. I say PDZ is underrated by the gaming community. I thought it was pretty good.RoslindaleOne