So it seems Gears of War 3 failed to defeat Uncharted 2 score...

Lemmings said that Gears of War 3 will be the best exclusive this gen, defeating Uncharted 2

Unfortunately in MC, Gears of War 3 only scored 91 while Uncharted 2 scored 96

And forza only scored 8.5 here

So after Gears of War 3 and Forza 4 failed to defeat Uncharted 2, is there any 360 exclusives that can defeat Uncharted 2? considering there's no 360 exclusives again this year

They said it would be the best exclusive this gen?

Anyway, why does something need to defeat UC2? It's a fantastic game with a score to match. So is Gears 3.

gears is better than uncharted.....mems_1224

gears is better than uncharted.....mems_1224

I'm sure many people would agree. I'm sure many think the contrary as well. Personally, I like them both as much as each other.

gears is better than uncharted.....mems_1224

both are good but to be honest outside the shooting mechanic its like comparing apples and oranges.

ONLY a 91. That's nothing. Personal opinion still, cause gears beats uncharted.LustForSoul

ONLY a 91. That's nothing. Personal opinion still, cause gears beats uncharted.LustForSoul

[QUOTE="LustForSoul"]ONLY a 91. That's nothing. Personal opinion still, cause gears beats uncharted.StrongDeadlift

Or perhaps he'll enjoy superiority over those dictated by meaningless numbers. ;)

[QUOTE="LustForSoul"]ONLY a 91. That's nothing. Personal opinion still, cause gears beats uncharted.StrongDeadlift

Metal Gear Solid 4 > Uncharted 2 = SMG1/2 > the rest of the games

[QUOTE="LustForSoul"]ONLY a 91. That's nothing. Personal opinion still, cause gears beats uncharted.StrongDeadlift

Metal Gear Solid 4 > Uncharted 2 = SMG1/2 > the rest of the games

Mozelleple112

[QUOTE="Ninja-Hippo"]Why do you use MC when the score is lower than Gamespot, but Gamespot when the score is lower than MC? StrongDeadlift

They're about equal in my eyes.

[QUOTE="StrongDeadlift"][QUOTE="LustForSoul"]ONLY a 91. That's nothing. Personal opinion still, cause gears beats uncharted.mmmwksil

Or perhaps he'll enjoy superiority over those dictated by meaningless numbers. ;)

but hey, if sub par experiences are your thing....

[spoiler] For those who could not figure it out on the last page, I was blatantly trolling. I do not actually believe the opinion expressed above, nor the one on the last page. Both games will be excellent and I am buying them both. [/spoiler]

[QUOTE="mmmwksil"]

[QUOTE="StrongDeadlift"] Yes, that is your personal opinion, however the metacritic score dissagrees with you. Enjoy inferiority :)StrongDeadlift

Or perhaps he'll enjoy superiority over those dictated by meaningless numbers. ;)

but hey, if sub par experiences are your thing....

You're still letting a number some random person slapped on the game determine what's good in your eyes.

[QUOTE="mmmwksil"]

[QUOTE="StrongDeadlift"] Yes, that is your personal opinion, however the metacritic score dissagrees with you. Enjoy inferiority :)StrongDeadlift

Or perhaps he'll enjoy superiority over those dictated by meaningless numbers. ;)

but hey, if sub par experiences are your thing....

[QUOTE="StrongDeadlift"][QUOTE="LustForSoul"]ONLY a 91. That's nothing. Personal opinion still, cause gears beats uncharted.Lexter45

[QUOTE="StrongDeadlift"]

[QUOTE="mmmwksil"]

Or perhaps he'll enjoy superiority over those dictated by meaningless numbers. ;)

mmmwksil

but hey, if sub par experiences are your thing....

You're still letting a number some random person slapped on the game determine what's good in your eyes.

[QUOTE="Lexter45"][QUOTE="StrongDeadlift"] Yes, that is your personal opinion, however the metacritic score dissagrees with you. Enjoy inferiority :)ianuilliam

I can write a detailed and Profesional Review on why Uncharted 2 deserves a 1 out of 10, does that mean it actually does and my opinion should be held higher than others?

[QUOTE="mmmwksil"]

[QUOTE="StrongDeadlift"] Or perhaps I will enjoy BOTH, over those who have to pick one :). However, in the unfortunate event that I DID have to pick one, it wouldnt be the inferior sub par one. But hey, maybe sub-par-ness is your thing. If you are comfortable with mediocrity, all the power to you. Some people aspire to work towards the proverbial Beamer or Mercadies in life, and others are content with the metaphorical christler 300s of life.

but hey, if sub par experiences are your thing....

StrongDeadlift

You're still letting a number some random person slapped on the game determine what's good in your eyes.

I had a feeling you were trolling. :P You take it a bit farther than usual, so people get confused.

[QUOTE="StrongDeadlift"][QUOTE="mmmwksil"]

You're still letting a number some random person slapped on the game determine what's good in your eyes.

mmmwksil

I had a feeling you were trolling. :P You take it a bit farther than usual, so people get confused.

[QUOTE="ianuilliam"]

[QUOTE="Lexter45"] You're saying it's just his opinion, that's all MC is... a bunch of opinions...Lexter45

I can write a detailed and Profesional Review on why Uncharted 2 deserves a 1 out of 10, does that mean it actually does and my opinion should be held higher than others?

[QUOTE="Lexter45"]

[QUOTE="ianuilliam"]Yeah, but while one's own personal opinion should be the most important for each individual person, it prevents any kind of consensus. When discussing which game is better overall, not just in your own personal opinion, average opinion of professional critics (whose job is to rate the quality of games, and are generally trusted by both the industry and the general gaming populace to do so) > opinion of one professional critic > opinion of any one random gamer.

ianuilliam

I can write a detailed and Profesional Review on why Uncharted 2 deserves a 1 out of 10, does that mean it actually does and my opinion should be held higher than others?

[QUOTE="ianuilliam"]

[QUOTE="Lexter45"]

I can write a detailed and Profesional Review on why Uncharted 2 deserves a 1 out of 10, does that mean it actually does and my opinion should be held higher than others?

Lexter45

Oh, and IGN is the largest gaming website on the internet btw, with Gamespot being the second.

Oh, and IGN is the largest gaming website on the internet btw, with Gamespot being the second.

StrongDeadlift

We all know Glitchspot is still the coolest, though. ;)

[QUOTE="Lexter45"][QUOTE="ianuilliam"]Yeah... as soon as you go get hired by an industry-respected gaming journalism mag/site. Of course as soon as you write that review, whichever mag/site you worked for would probably pull the review and fire you for making them look like over-the-top fanboys.

StrongDeadlift

Oh, and IGN is the largest gaming website on the internet btw, with Gamespot being the second.

Lemmings said that Gears of War 3 will be the best exclusive this gen, defeating Uncharted 2

Unfortunately in MC, Gears of War 3 only scored 91 while Uncharted 2 scored 96

And forza only scored 8.5 here

So after Gears of War 3 and Forza 4 failed to defeat Uncharted 2, is there any 360 exclusives that can defeat Uncharted 2? considering there's no 360 exclusives again this year

ihsanqueen

Yay.Nobody cares.

Wait TC, did you say Gears 3 got 9.1 on MC and Forza 4 8.5 here? Very clever double standards!

I would say Gears 3 got 9.5 here and Forza 4 9.2 on MC :P

On topic, standards change and opinions vary. Gears 3 is two years younger and, in my opinion, one of the best exclusives on any system.

you cant have a good game without the cole train baby WHOOOOO

Good points. Uncharted 2 is 6th in best scoring games of ALL time. I feel that's why U3 will flop here. Heil68

Early damage control, i see :P

Let´s be optimistic here. Uncharted 3 will most likelly be AAA on gamespot.

I think Uncharted 2 is the better game in my opinion, but so what if the game scored higher. IfGears 3 isa good game than it's a good game. People take scores too literally around here. Plus I am tired of the Uncharted vs Gears threads.

I LOL when people act like a game getting a 91 score is horrible. Who cares if Unchated 2 got higher rated than Gears 3? Doesn't mean it's better or that Gears 3 is bad. This is all matter of opinion and personal taste.

[QUOTE="StrongDeadlift"]

[QUOTE="Lexter45"] Why do9 I have to be hired by an Industry respected Gaming Journalist site? Does having IGN on my review somehow increase its quality :?Lexter45

Oh, and IGN is the largest gaming website on the internet btw, with Gamespot being the second.

i wish someone would make a similar game that objectively destroys uncharted and gears in every aspect, that way both sides would have to shut up lolTH1Sx1SxSPARTA

[QUOTE="Lexter45"][QUOTE="StrongDeadlift"] Yes it does actually. Especially considering Metacritic weighs each website in its system by how credible it is, and more larger sites have a higher weight on the overall score. IGN and Gamespot scores have a larger weight than smaller, lesser known sites. Not to mention, there is criteria you have to meet before you are even eligible to be calculated. You cant just put together a no name blog, and post it up there. There is criteria you have to meet, and they review your website.

Oh, and IGN is the largest gaming website on the internet btw, with Gamespot being the second.

ianuilliam

If we arere talking average score and using Metacritic you'd be right, nothing has touched Uncharted 2 yet and I predict Uncharted 3 to score on average above 95 aswell. There's just no helping it, uncharted is arguably the best game series of this generation.

1. Gears 3 > UC2
2. Only GS scores count
3. No one said Gears 3 would be the best exclusive this gen.