Need New Game

Hello all,

I am writing to ask what game I should get. The primary functions of this game:

1. High replay value.
2. Should NOT be NHL 12, FIFA 12, Twisted Metal, Battlefield 3, MW3
3. Replay value should come from online play. However, if there is an exception, game will not be automatically disqualified.

I need something new and am open to pretty much anything.

Thank you

Get an RPG with tons of replay value, like Skyrim or Dragon Age. If you haven't played Mass Effect 2 yet, get that. These games you can get fairly cheap too.