Penumbra: Collectors Pack vs Amnesia Dark Descent?

Two great horror games by the same dev. They are both 20 bucks, and both on steam, and now I can't decide. I would probably get more content with Penumbra, but I heard Amnesia has the edge gameplay wise. What do you guys think?

Buy it from the official store instead. Same price but more goes to the developers instead of a big evil corp like Valve. The official store also got the Linux port.

Buy it from the official store instead. Same price but more goes to the developers instead of a big evil corp like Valve. The official store also got the Linux port.

Ensamheten

http://www.rockpapershotgun.com/2010/08/23/how-a-steam-promotion-saved-introversion/

Amnesia has more bang for your buck and has a editor with player made missions.

Pen is also awesome but leave that for a other time. :)

Wait for Holiday sale.

I hated the forced combat on Penumbra Overture (Hadn't played any of the other games on the series, but the first one wasn't frightening or as good as people said it was), so get Amnesia.

[QUOTE="Ensamheten"]

Buy it from the official store instead. Same price but more goes to the developers instead of a big evil corp like Valve. The official store also got the Linux port.

thespywholied

http://www.rockpapershotgun.com/2010/08/23/how-a-steam-promotion-saved-introversion/

That could have been and digital download retailer.

But more money going to the developer is definately a good thing

penumbra overture was good.. cuz it was realtisic

all the others sucked too much unrealistic religous cult stuff

just get overture

[QUOTE="Ensamheten"]

Buy it from the official store instead. Same price but more goes to the developers instead of a big evil corp like Valve. The official store also got the Linux port.

thespywholied

http://www.rockpapershotgun.com/2010/08/23/how-a-steam-promotion-saved-introversion/

lol you both responded but didn't vote! And didn't give your opinion....Essian

I couldnt decide myself and I broke down bought both.

I couldnt decide myself and I broke down bought both.

theshadowhunter

Still an evil corporation. They allow $1 = €1, they only relealse on plattforms controled by americans to protect american interests, they destory games with bad updates leaving the purchaser empty handed, they released L4D2 9 months after L4D1. DONT SUPPORT THEM! I'd also like to add: EU SHOULD EFFING BAN THEM

Ensamheten

What do you mean by "platforms controlled by americans"? First its platform (notice without s),secibd Steam only caters to PC which is not owned by any one corporation, besides even if Steam wanted to cater to consoles they wouldn't, MS and Sony would never allow a service that will compete with their own, which would be ironic since they own the platform.

In the end Valve is just like thousands of other businesses out there, it has the same objective -- making money.

On-topic, personally I'd get both, wait for the sale, with Black Friday and Xmas coming, you could very probably get both for the price of one.

[QUOTE="Ensamheten"]

Still an evil corporation. They allow $1 = €1, they only relealse on plattforms controled by americans to protect american interests, they destory games with bad updates leaving the purchaser empty handed, they released L4D2 9 months after L4D1. DONT SUPPORT THEM! I'd also like to add: EU SHOULD EFFING BAN THEM

Gamerz1569

What do you mean by "platforms controlled by americans"? First its platform (notice without s),secibd Steam only caters to PC which is not owned by any one corporation, besides even if Steam wanted to cater to consoles they wouldn't, MS and Sony would never allow a service that will compete with their own, which would be ironic since they own the platform.

In the end Valve is just like thousands of other businesses out there, it has the same objective -- making money.

On-topic, personally I'd get both, wait for the sale, with Black Friday and Xmas coming, you could very probably get both for the price of one.

Buy it from the official store instead. Same price but more goes to the developers instead of a big evil corp like Valve. The official store also got the Linux port.

Ensamheten

[QUOTE="Ensamheten"]

Buy it from the official store instead. Same price but more goes to the developers instead of a big evil corp like Valve. The official store also got the Linux port.

jimmyjammer69