This topic is locked from further discussion.
Thats ridiculous, his newfound belief that hell probably isnt what most people think makes a lot more sense to me, and I believe would be a better thing to teach people than "go to church, be christian, go to heaven. If not burn in hell".
I lol'd. It is kind of funny how religion in organized religions have become an absolute, and not a dicussion of what "is real" and what "is not." Like it has been throughout history.
I'm no Christian, but being a pastor is all about following Christianity as it is. This is the very basic foundation of a religion. If you don't believe in the said religion then you can't be a member of such role as a pastor. Explain to me how this is wrong please.GazaAliNot believing in hell =/= not believing in Christianity.
That's like thinking that believing in equal rights for women means you don't believe in Islam.
Not believing in hell =/= not believing in Christianity.[QUOTE="GazaAli"]I'm no Christian, but being a pastor is all about following Christianity as it is. This is the very basic foundation of a religion. If you don't believe in the said religion then you can't be a member of such role as a pastor. Explain to me how this is wrong please.Theokhoth
That's like thinking that believing in equal rights for women means you don't believe in Islam.
he should just go create his own non-hell branch of christianity... hell there's already how many branches? why not 1 more?[QUOTE="GazaAli"]I'm no Christian, but being a pastor is all about following Christianity as it is. This is the very basic foundation of a religion. If you don't believe in the said religion then you can't be a member of such role as a pastor. Explain to me how this is wrong please.TheokhothNot believing in hell =/= not believing in Christianity. ok but you diverge from it at least. We all know that Religions and specifically the Abrahamic religions are all about "believing in the entirety" and when you defy this rule, you lose your right to classify yourself as a member of one of these religions. I'm not saying this is good, and I'm not saying this is bad either, I'm just stating the facts of these religions.
[QUOTE="Theokhoth"]Not believing in hell =/= not believing in Christianity.[QUOTE="GazaAli"]I'm no Christian, but being a pastor is all about following Christianity as it is. This is the very basic foundation of a religion. If you don't believe in the said religion then you can't be a member of such role as a pastor. Explain to me how this is wrong please.comp_atkins
That's like thinking that believing in equal rights for women means you don't believe in Islam.
he should just go create his own non-hell branch of christianity... hell there's already how many branches? why not 1 more? exactly. Don't expect to say such a thing and still claim your position as a pastor.[QUOTE="Theokhoth"][QUOTE="GazaAli"]I'm no Christian, but being a pastor is all about following Christianity as it is. This is the very basic foundation of a religion. If you don't believe in the said religion then you can't be a member of such role as a pastor. Explain to me how this is wrong please.GazaAliNot believing in hell =/= not believing in Christianity. ok but you diverge from it at least. We all know that Religions and specifically the Abrahamic religions are all about "believing in the entirety" and when you defy this rule, you lose your right to classify yourself as a member of one of these religions. I'm not saying this is good, and I'm not saying this is bad either, I'm just stating the facts of these religions. It's debatable as to what "the entirety" actually is. Where one Christian might say gays are going to hell, another might say there's nothing christian about this belief. Nothing in life is quite so simple as that, religion least of all.
[QUOTE="comp_atkins"][QUOTE="fidosim"]He should nail his 95 theses to the church door.fidosimewwww... oh wait. theses... It would be hard to nail feces to anything. :? zip-loc bag?
[QUOTE="Theokhoth"][QUOTE="GazaAli"]I'm no Christian, but being a pastor is all about following Christianity as it is. This is the very basic foundation of a religion. If you don't believe in the said religion then you can't be a member of such role as a pastor. Explain to me how this is wrong please.GazaAliNot believing in hell =/= not believing in Christianity. ok but you diverge from it at least. We all know that Religions and specifically the Abrahamic religions are all about "believing in the entirety" and when you defy this rule, you lose your right to classify yourself as a member of one of these religions. I'm not saying this is good, and I'm not saying this is bad either, I'm just stating the facts of these religions.
There's plenty of Christians who don't believe in Hell, or at least not the traditional concept of it. An old pastor of mine believed it to be a state of being cut off from God rather than a place of eternal torture and punishment.
[QUOTE="fidosim"][QUOTE="comp_atkins"] ewwww... oh wait. theses...comp_atkinsIt would be hard to nail feces to anything. :? zip-loc bag?
Yeah if you want to take the easy route I guess. In your last thread they didnt take the easy route with a retractable roof, no. Flying ships.
ok but you diverge from it at least. We all know that Religions and specifically the Abrahamic religions are all about "believing in the entirety" and when you defy this rule, you lose your right to classify yourself as a member of one of these religions. I'm not saying this is good, and I'm not saying this is bad either, I'm just stating the facts of these religions.[QUOTE="GazaAli"][QUOTE="Theokhoth"] Not believing in hell =/= not believing in Christianity.worlock77
There's plenty of Christians who don't believe in Hell, or at least not the traditional concept of it. An old pastor of mine believed it to be a state of being cut off from God rather than a place of eternal torture and punishment.
Wouldn't being cut off from God be torture and punishment?[QUOTE="worlock77"][QUOTE="GazaAli"] ok but you diverge from it at least. We all know that Religions and specifically the Abrahamic religions are all about "believing in the entirety" and when you defy this rule, you lose your right to classify yourself as a member of one of these religions. I'm not saying this is good, and I'm not saying this is bad either, I'm just stating the facts of these religions.ferrari2001
There's plenty of Christians who don't believe in Hell, or at least not the traditional concept of it. An old pastor of mine believed it to be a state of being cut off from God rather than a place of eternal torture and punishment.
Wouldn't being cut off from God be torture and punishment?Not in the sense that most people think of when they think of Hell. Think of it more like being in a place with no light rather than being lashed with chain whips or drowned in boiling blood or whatnot.
As for the argument of "There are a lot of christians who don't believe in hell", I know there are, but I doubt that they follow churches that do believe in hell. This is kind of similar to saying "I want to be a Muslim and pray in a church". There are many branches in Christianity, and some of them may not believe in hell. This particular church does believe in hell. If you want to be a pastor there, you will have to a Christian who believes in hell.GazaAli
Only that's not what you were saying. You were saying that one must believe in Hell if one wants to call themself a Christian.
[QUOTE="GazaAli"]As for the argument of "There are a lot of christians who don't believe in hell", I know there are, but I doubt that they follow churches that do believe in hell. This is kind of similar to saying "I want to be a Muslim and pray in a church". There are many branches in Christianity, and some of them may not believe in hell. This particular church does believe in hell. If you want to be a pastor there, you will have to a Christian who believes in hell.worlock77
Only that's not what you were saying. You were saying that one must believe in Hell if one wants to call themself a Christian.
uhhh no,. He said that you need to believe in hell to be pastor at that church.
Wouldn't being cut off from God be torture and punishment?[QUOTE="ferrari2001"][QUOTE="worlock77"]
There's plenty of Christians who don't believe in Hell, or at least not the traditional concept of it. An old pastor of mine believed it to be a state of being cut off from God rather than a place of eternal torture and punishment.
worlock77
Not in the sense that most people think of when they think of Hell. Think of it more like being in a place with no light rather than being lashed with chain whips or drowned in boiling blood or whatnot.
Well the common Christian belief is that it is more of a state of being rather than a specified place. We can't describe hell just as we can't describe heaven. If you believe in the traditional understanding of God, than being separated from him would be worse than any physical torture. Could there be physical torture as well, yes, but without a body until the final judgement physical torture wouldn't work so well.[QUOTE="worlock77"][QUOTE="ferrari2001"] Wouldn't being cut off from God be torture and punishment?ferrari2001
Not in the sense that most people think of when they think of Hell. Think of it more like being in a place with no light rather than being lashed with chain whips or drowned in boiling blood or whatnot.
Well the common Christian belief is that it is more of a state of being rather than a specified place. We can't describe hell just as we can't describe heaven. If you believe in the traditional understanding of God, than being separated from him would be worse than any physical torture. Could there be physical torture as well, yes, but without a body until the final judgement physical torture wouldn't work so well.Yes its a state of being completely seperate from god, the worst torcher any one can have.
this has nothing to do with bashing religion. It has to do with a community outing their pastor for doing something that all religious leaders have done throughout history, questioned the faith in order to give people something to think about and increase their faith through discovery of themselves and their own beliefs. Not selling a product.Oh boy another thread for OT to bash religion. :roll:
Ragnarok1051
Wouldn't being cut off from God be torture and punishment?ferrari2001
Makes sense to me. You shouldn't be a priest/pastor if you don't believe your own religion. Religion should be open to different interpretations, sure, but not if you want to be in charge of it.Ninja-HippoI think this is pretty straight forward and yet it amazes me that some people are actually debating this and blaming the church. This is like being a sexist and a member of a feminist party.
pfft, modern religion has lost it's way.
his hand strapped down and a pair of pliers for those sinning fingernails and this heresy would be history.
gimme that old tyme religion! :P
Sure you can question the bible's teachings and what it means anytime. After all if we didn't let people do that the religion wouldn't have changed so much in the last 2000 years. But don't you dare question the part where we threaten people with eternal damnation for minor things if they don't convert and give us money >:IAce6301
This was a methodist church they believe very stongly in what they believe. Other denominations would be a more leniant
[QUOTE="Ace6301"]Sure you can question the bible's teachings and what it means anytime. After all if we didn't let people do that the religion wouldn't have changed so much in the last 2000 years. But don't you dare question the part where we threaten people with eternal damnation for minor things if they don't convert and give us money >:IFundai
This was a methodist church they believe very stongly in what they believe. Other denominations would be a more leniant
It's a protestant church who's roots go back to the Church of England... You would think they would be a bit more accepting of new ideas by definition of their history.I don't see a problem with that, to be honest. It would be like a buddhist teacher speaking against reincarnation or a sikh teacher speaking againt the 5 Ks.
Congregations fire pastors all the time because they don't like what they are preaching.
Officer Barbrady says: "Move along people. Nothing to see here."
"Blessed are you when people insult you, persecute you and falsely say all kinds of evil against you because of me. Rejoice and be glad, because great is your reward in heaven, for in the same way they persecuted the prophets who were before you." (Matthew 5:11-12)
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment