[QUOTE="GTA_dude"][QUOTE="YourChaosIsntMe"] First, don't get too serious man. BMWs are expensive to maintain when you need to replace parts, provided you're going to put a BMW certified part in the vehicle. I don't consider third-party parts a legitimate factor in maintenance costs. Manufacturer certified (or at least accepted industry-wide) or it isn't going in my car. They only cost less if you can pull your own used parts and install them yourself. Simply by the very nature of BMW dealers and certified third-party shops/tuners, they are more expensive to maintain than either a Mitsubishi or Pontiac. You can have a Trans Am worked on for less than $40 an hour labor fees from a reputable shop.
Most people are not you and I. Most people will simply choose to bring their vehicle to a shop. A BMW or an old Porsche is only cheap to maintain if you can maintain it yourself; be realistic, we're the exception, not the rule. But, that point is moot. An old BMW or a new Jetta is still a better option than a Trans Am, regardless of the minor cost increase.
Yes, I know that you don't order parts from "there." That isn't the point. The company which ultimately owns the products - whether they are manufactured in Germany by the company or a subsidiary, or in Mexico by a sub-contractor, is based in Germany. I didn't mean that as a simplistic statement. My car has parts manufactured all over the world, though primarily in Mexico, Germany, and U.S. Then it is assembled in Mexico. Regardless of this, VW-Audi (and BMW) operate on the Euro, which affects pricing for vehicles and parts in the U.S. (well, not so much now as 10 months ago).
I disagree on Porsche. Porsche is in the same category. All of the manufacturers have or had exorbitantly priced super cars (BMW M1, M2 and M3 GTR, Porsche 911/C. GT, M-B McLaren, Audi R8, Bugatti (VW) Veyron). The vast majority of vehicles in Porsche's history belies your statement that Porsche are something different. 922, 924, 944, 928, Boxster, Cayman. In fact, the 944 Turbo is my next car. The 944 is a contender in that class, or was while it was still in production.
Dub_c6969
Lol, your the one who took my first post serious, you did edit that quote twice.... And any car is expensive to work on if you go to a certified place to work on it (Dealers are a ***** if you take your car to one, any car). And Trans Ams are only cheap because they've been so popular and there are sooo many aftermarket parts from them. But either way, unless your getting a crappy 3rd gen, it will still cost you more to purchase the car then it would to buy an E36 (I've looked at them), and they are still not that reliable. Odds are you'd have to take the trans am to the shop enough times to where it would cost you the same as a bmw your describing. And alot of shops (Or atleast here) dont care what your car is, they'll work on it anyway for the same labor price.And who says I'm not putting certified parts on my car? Some parts are, some arn't. It all depends on whether or not it matters. Like, head gasket with head bolts, dealer parts, fuel filter, autozone, camshaft position sensor, off the internet. Most parts are from the dealer though, I just got them cheaper then they would sell them. And I'd imagine if your putting alot of thought into your first car and you expect to modify it, you'd do alot of work yourself, and it would be a really good opportunity to learn about working on cars too.
And yah, each has its own higher priced car, but thats not my point, I was talking about a certain class of cars. Cheap, small, front engine, 4 seater sport coupes/sedans that are Realistically in the price range for a first car. The 928/944 are the closest to this class (And they are also hella cheap), I give you that, but they are still not in the car class I was talking about. And the 928/944 compared to the 3000GT, I'd probably go with the 3000GT. 944's also are the worst porsche ever made, other then the 914.
And I'm interested in the M2 you mentioned?
So you would trust some American auto work shop to work on a foreign car? Is that even possible? I only ask because my folks only take their BMW to the certified BMW workshop because they believe they are the only ones who can really work on the car besides those High mod places like Alpina,Dinan etc etc. Lol, I only trust myself and my dad to even touch my car. Cause anyone else working on your car doesn't actually care for the car, they only care about the money they're making.And you know, basically every car is exactly the same with only minor differences. If you can work on one, you can work on them all, doesn't matter what country it came from. Yeah, the quality and experiences differs from place to place, but that also includes dealers. Sometimes the dealers dont know **** about the cars they are working on, the people actually doing the work on the cars can be the same kinda people you'd find working on your car at Pep Boys.....
But then again, some of the dealers can be better then another shop. I guess it all goes off of who you want to trust. I've talked to guys at the BMW dealership here in Phoenix the other day, and I knew more about my car then they did. Seriously, those guys in the parts department where idiots, I was asking for a part and I was just talking over their heads or something. A guy who I work with is going to school to work at a dealership, and he just barely finished school, I was talking to him about a problem with my car a few months ago, and he had no clue what to do (I fixed the problem easily though without his help, I just wanted to see if he would know).
Edit: But dont take this as a way of me telling you to not go where ever your use to going to get your car fixed, cause I dont care what your doing. If its working fine, then just stick with the same shop. I'm just saying, non certified places arn't that bad
Log in to comment