Poll: Best Medieval Fantasy RPG for consoles

Since Witcher 2 is out for consoles, I just wanted to make this poll and ask, "What is your pick as the best RPG for consoles that is based on medieval fantasy?"

My pick has to be Dark Souls.

At the moment its DA O but hopefully the Witcher 2 takes the cake.

Dark Souls is way too punishing for me. I am for Skyrim. I hope one day I will be able to patiently tackle Dark Souls. I even bought the guidebook with the game a month or so ago. I kept going back to KoA though. Skyrim for sure

SKyrim for sure.

TW2 > DAO > DS > Skyrim

Any Elder Scrolls game

Nothing can even touch the amount of life, immersion, realism & variety these games bring. Im going to steal a quote from Edge Magazine speaking about Morrowind:

"Theres an entire culture to ingest & digest, covering polotics, religion, geography, guilds, lore, drugs, booze, disease, flora, fauna & even books"

There is simply nothing that even comes close to doing what the ES has done. It continues to be the best & most fully realized world, fantasy with every release. Here's a quick 2 minute example of why ES is so amazing. You guys should take a look at this:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5kkurXgkkfg&context=C438dce4ADvjVQa1PpcFPuCTh2PKE-ONtvHhWxhWdtwGkTc8sbWZM=

Any Elder Scrolls game

Nothing can even touch the amount of life, immersion, realism & variety these games bring. Im going to steal a quote from Edge Magazine speaking about Morrowind:

"Theres an entire culture to ingest & digest, covering polotics, religion, geography, guilds, lore, drugs, booze, disease, flora, fauna & even books"

There is simply nothing that even comes close to doing what the ES has done. It continues to be the best & most fully realized world, fantasy with every release. Here's a quick 2 minute example of why ES is so amazing. You guys should take a look at this:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5kkurXgkkfg&context=C438dce4ADvjVQa1PpcFPuCTh2PKE-ONtvHhWxhWdtwGkTc8sbWZM=

brucecambell

I'm not sure I'd call the setting of Skyrim, Fable II or Kingdoms of Amalur a Medieval Fantasy setting :/.

Skyrim is number one. I havent played The Witcher 2 yet, but i fully expect it to be second or third placed. The last game that forms is the BIG 3 is Two Worlds 2 which is a darn good game.

Haven't been too impressed with medieval fantasy RPG's this gen. There's a sameness about them - a lack of genuine creativity. If it hasn't been done in the other, similar games of this gen, then we can't do it in our game. But there are several I've yet to play. Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning looks very interesting.

My favorite is still Drakan: The Ancient Gates from the PS2. You got to fly around on a dragon, and have dragon vs. dragon battles in midair, and strafe bad guys on the ground. The variety of environments was fabulous, and I actually cared about the main character and completing her quest.

Dragon Age Origins was really good.