Review

Nether Review

  • First Released Jun 5, 2014
    released
  • PC

Give and take.

GameSpot may get a commission from retail offers.

The popularity of postapocalyptic survival games has been explosive, and it has become increasingly critical to offer a fresh take or risk being lost in the bedlam. Nether, however, is a first-person online survival shooter that doesn't strive to reinvent the wheel. It approaches the challenge by introducing tried-and-true ideas, mashing them together in hopes that the sum of its acclimated parts results in a bright entry in the well-trodden genre. What emerges is a concoction that vacillates between amusement and listlessness. Nether employs many ideas that, alone, could have produced enjoyable gameplay, but what ultimately surfaces is a game whose fun, interesting moments are undermined by frustration.

Nether exhibits influences from popular postapocalyptic television shows and films. The Chicago-inspired urban sprawl of the city portions of the game are home to cracked, ruined skyscrapers and flooded streets. Vehicles, covered in rust and abandoned by their owners, litter enormous freeways in a scene that could have been plucked from early advertisements for The Walking Dead. Scattered throughout the world are safe zones, hastily erected out of metal barriers or standing high on platforms. Final bastions of humankind, safe zones are places similar to the cobbled structures seen in films like The Day of the Dead. Here, you are safe from harm (mostly, but more on that later) and can buy and sell gear, craft weapons, and complete courier missions.

The dilapidated world of Nether is beautiful and dangerous.
The dilapidated world of Nether is beautiful and dangerous.

Despite the familiar world in which Nether exists, I found the varied urban environments the highlight of my forlorn adventures. As is the custom of survival games, you are released into the desolate world of Nether, where you're greeted by ruined buildings and charred skeletons. No explanation behind the tragedy is freely offered, only a large kitchen knife and a lime-green backpack, the latter of which does little to assist you in blending into the brown and gray of the decayed urban landscape. Scattered throughout the broken concrete world are signs of the desperation that soon followed whatever unearthly disaster occurred years prior. Emergency vehicles sit dormant, their flashing lights cutting through the dust and fog.

Elsewhere lay signs that people had attempted to carve out an existence, either in peaceful solitude or in ruthless, violent gangs--both of which ultimately met a macabre and bloody demise. The world is bleak, dark, often gorgeous, and well realized. I embraced the excitement and apprehension as I darted into buildings or sprinted over dangerous, empty streets while scrounging for food or gear locked away in various objects such as vending machines or abandoned vehicles. Some minor gripes include buildings that are clearly copied and pasted, and structures that cannot be entered.

Shops located in safe zones sell gear and accessories.
Shops located in safe zones sell gear and accessories.

But those issues don't hamper the entertainment much. Adding to the interest is the ambient weather system, which can influence how you approach situations. More than once, I would scout an area I needed to visit. I noted pathways to keep me hidden, along with enemies to avoid. But suddenly a cloud of rust-colored dust would roll in, and the loss of vision would force me to drastically alter my advancement. Nether's fluctuating world feels like a living entity, always plotting against you.

It's unfortunate that the immersion is so often broken by nagging issues, coupled with the reality of Nether's clearly unfinished state. Oddly placed invisible walls stop you short mid-sprint, which makes pacing anything but fluid. Piles of rubble and trash are commonplace, which is not strange considering the game's motif. What is odd, however, are the invisible barriers surrounding the debris. Walking over the piles is possible, though doing so positions you several feet in the air. Your movement speed is also drastically slowed in these situations, turning you into an easy target for predators. It is also possible to clip completely into certain objects, such as cabinets, computer desks, or rubble, as well as some knee-high gates, as if they weren't even there. The fields west of the city may seem like a respite from such urban difficulties, but they are nearly barren and devoid of food and resources--save for the military grain silo, a popular site for random weapon spawns. There are towers to capture if you're part of a clan, as well as safe zones to which you can transport packages. I found myself avoiding the area completely and sticking to the more interesting urban locations.

Scattered throughout the broken concrete world are signs of the desperation that soon followed whatever unearthly disaster occurred years prior.

The creatures that populate the world following the collapse of society are the titular nethers. These mutated abominations come in many forms and charge with sharp claws, blunt fists, or blinding toxic sludge. Running is not always an option, because the monsters possess the ability to dive into a portal, exiting just behind your back and slashing away at you. These abilities make nethers more threatening than the average shuffling zombie. But some of the danger they pose also comes from their hypersensitive threat detection.

Nethers have the uncanny ability to "sense" you through stone, asphalt, and metal. You might believe you're alone as you move through an empty building, but suddenly a deafening screech informs you that a nether is on your tail. It can get frustrating, especially if you're being careful not to get spotted while you go about your current goal, whether it's traveling to a location or searching around for loot. Killing the creatures makes them drop organic parts such as blood or claws, which can then be sold or traded at the Order of the Cull, a mysterious group that exchanges nether viscera for gear. The order can also craft weapons from nether bones, once you gather enough severed parts.

No Caption Provided
Tough enough to take out the nether reaper? Get ready for a fight.
Tough enough to take out the nether reaper? Get ready for a fight.

More dangerous than the nethers are the human players who populate the world with you. Encounters with players are rarely analogous to those in other survival games such as DayZ, where you can consider teaming up with people, or tie them up and force-feed them any noxious chemicals in the area if you're feeling especially sadistic. But there is still a chance for a budding friendship in that harsh world. Not once, however, in my entire 30-hour run in Nether did I experience a confrontation that did not result in one player trying to immediately kill another; the game is the epitome of the "kill or be killed" axiom. Especially frustrating are times when snipers camp just outside the protective sphere surrounding safe zones and pick off players just as their protection timer reaches zero. Shouting "friendly," the multiplayer-game-wide attempt at offering an olive branch of peace, is generally rewarded with a hail of gunfire. Camaraderie is rarely experienced, even during in-game missions.

On occasion, Nether starts a timed mission and places you randomly on the map. You receive periodic warnings of a nether surge in need of clearing or an escort package to deliver. The game's version of a boss, the nether reaper, a massive and shockingly fast beast, also appears at times, providing a challenge for veteran players or groups. If you join a clan, you can take out one of many strategically placed clan strongholds in a mode that mimic's Battlefield 4's Conquest mode. These missions can put Nether experts through their paces, and the game suggests grouping up to complete them. Unless you play with friends, or manage to band a small team together, however, players' general proclivity toward violence in Nether makes working collectively to complete missions difficult.

It's unfortunate that the immersion is so often broken by nagging issues, coupled with the reality of Nether's clearly unfinished state.

Worst of all are the times defenses in safe zones drop and you must reactivate pieces of machinery to get them back up. The game, it seems, expects players to work together in this dire time of need. But with defenses gone, people are free to shoot each other indiscriminately. So you can get where this is leading. Only once in several instances did I witness players working together with the goal of reviving the safe zone. Every other time was a massacre, and only the smartest (or fastest) players were able to get out before being gunned down.

I found that having enough people in a server was necessary for enjoyment, however. Sure, a fellow player who offers a friendly wave in a safe zone might later greet you with that hand tightly wrapped around the grip of a gun. But without the tension that can only be delivered by random encounters with actual living players, the game devolves into a long and uneventful trek through austere scenery. I enjoyed exploring the game's environments, but I eventually got bored and went on the hunt for populated servers when the one I inhabited began to droop.

No Caption Provided
Band together to take on missions, and hope you don't get betrayed.
Band together to take on missions, and hope you don't get betrayed.

To survive in the hostile world of Nether, you must equip yourself with the proper tools. Guns and melee weapons are not in short supply, though the former requires you to collect parts. Weapon parts, such as grips, barrels, and scopes, are found in containers located in the environment. When the parts are gathered, you can take them to a weapon crafter in any of the safe zones, where your brand-new gun will be assembled for free. Nether sports a wide variety of guns, from the always reliable 9mm Smith & Risley pistol, to a diverse selection of rifles and shotguns.

You start out with a basic knife, but to face tougher enemies, a stronger melee weapon is crucial. Melee weapons are sometimes found intact in some containers, but I was partial to purchasing them for a reasonable fee. Close-range combat is enjoyable, and you can feel the weight behind each swing of a machete or baseball bat. But guns are on the opposite end of the spectrum. They are powerful, but far too accurate, and they demonstrate next to nothing in the way of recoil. The guns bear more resemblance to weapons found in arena shooters, and fired bullets can be dodged by jumping around like a rabbit--a tactic adopted by veteran Nether players.

Completing missions and delivering packages awards you with cash and experience points. The experience points are used to bolster specific skills, such as stamina, accuracy, or melee damage. The game also awards you with a cash and experience point booster for every half an hour you're alive. And as is par for the course, rising in level is another joy that Nether likes to snatch away. Dying takes you back down to zero, which adds a lot of pressure the higher your level climbs. Going from level 25 back down to zero is frustrating, but luckily leveling up doesn't take much time. However, the constant sting of progression loss begins to have a numbing effect, and earning levels is quickly deprived of any gratification. You also have an account level, which isn't lost at death, but it advances far more slowly; I managed about one level per two hours. The account level adds permanent status boosters, and offers cash bonuses.

Only once in several instances did I witness players working together with the goal of reviving the safe zone.

Money can be spent on gear or food, or on cosmetic items such as masks, some of which pay homage to pop culture icons. Nether also includes a system in which you can exchange real-world money for nether gold, and you can buy special game packages from the Steam store that include this special currency. The gold does not go toward weapons, however, only cosmetic items; it's included for those who are too impatient to save up money to cosplay as Deadpool or the Master Chief.

Nether plays host to a number of glitches and irritating hang-ups. The game's engine isn't well optimized, and even if your computer is used to high-tier games, it will still struggle to render Nether's world. You can't swim, at least not in any traditional sense. Trying to tread water found in the western fields can get you hopelessly stuck, and drowning is an agonizingly slow process. If you need to bypass channels, you must hit the water while jumping to mimic the act of swimming. If you emerge alive, the water blurs your vision with a blue filter that lasts for around five seconds. Worse than that are sticking keys, which once caused me to accidentally walk out of a hole on the side of a multistory sky scraper. If you're up to the task, you can seek out Nether's infamous dune buggy, which has, uh, a few kinks that need to be ironed out. One you find it, the warning "USE AT YOUR OWN RISK" pops up onscreen. Some players have dubbed it the "buggy buggy," because driving it is a glitch-infused nightmare.

Safe zones offer brief sanctuary against nethers and enemy players.
Safe zones offer brief sanctuary against nethers and enemy players.

Regardless of everything that drags the game down, Nether provides some compelling moments and creates stories to share. Some of my favorite tales are composed of times I felt the desire to leave the streets and travel to my destination using the often underused subway system. The silence in the tunnels was therapeutic after the tension on the surface, for a time. In the subway, flickering lights supplement the lonely sound of your footsteps, which is abruptly broken by noise from the surface. Just above your head comes the sound of screeching demons, followed by the sharp crack of gunfire and then silence. The reality of the situation is enough to snap you back into focus, as it must, because soon the tunnel ends, and you once again have to face the light.

Such moments are fleeting, however, and dissipate just as you get accustomed to their sudden, yet welcome, company. Nether is noticeably unfinished, and has a lot of work ahead before it resembles a solid game. But it has a discernible spark of life. There is potential for it to become a game worthy of attention. The environment it presents is huge, and the grayed-out portions of the map serve to tease you with even more areas to explore, and stories to create, in its bleak, abysmal, yet interesting world. If only it can learn to stop tripping over its own feet.

Back To Top
The Good
The world is dark, often compelling, and well realized
Nothing beats the thrill of dodging players and enemies
Melee combat has a weighted, organic feel
The Bad
Immersion is harmed by invisible barriers and objects that can be clipped into
Enemy AI is too sensitive at times
Players don't cooperate even in co-op focused circumstances
Guns display arena-like performance
Bugs and glitches hamper the experience
5
Mediocre
About GameSpot's Reviews

About the Author

Cameron Woolsey has played many games where he spent untold hours fighting to survive against grueling odds. For the sake of this review, Cameron played for about 30 hours, reaching level 32 and an account level of 15.
20 Comments  RefreshSorted By 
GameSpot has a zero tolerance policy when it comes to toxic conduct in comments. Any abusive, racist, sexist, threatening, bullying, vulgar, and otherwise objectionable behavior will result in moderation and/or account termination. Please keep your discussion civil.

Avatar image for -JMD-
-JMD-

69

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 0

so the bad is that "Players don't cooperate even in co-op focused circumstances"


So its the game fault that peploe are asshooles!

Avatar image for r9270
R9270

31

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 2

User Lists: 5

Edited By R9270

This looks like a cheap imitation of fallout! Gary? GARRRRRYYYYYYYYYY!!!!!!!!!! GARY! Gary.

Avatar image for derikgw
derikgw

30

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 10

User Lists: 5

This game is crap. There is no penalty for being a bandit, not that I mind bandits, but when they pick you off over and over and over and over and over within an hour, and you only have a knife, there has GOT to be some sort of punishment system for being a bandit. The collision with various objects, like rock piles in the terrain, are still incredibly armature. This game has a lot of design flaws. I ended up uninstalling it.

Avatar image for Toysoldier34
Toysoldier34

2384

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 6

User Lists: 0

I've been really enjoying the game and having lots of fun with it as an early access game. Though when I heard it was full release I couldn't believe it because it still feels extremely early access with lots of bugs to it. The game doesn't have polish to it at all.


This is quite upsetting because I really enjoyed my time and looked forward to what it could be, only to realize that what I was getting was what I had the entire time, minus the microtransactions and cosmetic gear you can buy that they added at near launch instead of fixing bugs.

Avatar image for Caldrin
Caldrin

257

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 21

User Lists: 0

Well picked this up in the steam sale for a few £ and for that price the game is well worth it :)


Avatar image for misternathan
misternathan

93

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 2

User Lists: 0

Edited By misternathan

Incredibly accurate review. It was as if the reviewer was narrating my experience with the game. Good on ya.

Avatar image for chibistevo32
chibistevo32

25

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 2

User Lists: 0

These games will always fail, because of the players who play them.


Surviving the harsh apocalyptic world with random people sounds good on paper, but in the end, most are just there to shoot the hell out of people for bragging rights.


Until a dev can properly integrate a system whereby these decisions do not ultimately make the game feel like a pointless PvP shoot em up with a rarely realized gimmick, it's best to just not bother.

Avatar image for Divisionbell
Divisionbell

352

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 2

User Lists: 0

Agreed. It wouldn't be as bad if you didn't lose EVERYTHING every time you die, but as it stands now I just can't get into this game.

Avatar image for naryanrobinson
naryanrobinson

3028

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 7

User Lists: 0

Edited By naryanrobinson

Bit unfair to mention unsportsmanlike players in the review, although I can see where you're coming from at least.

Too many unfinished games these days. Glad they're not totally getting away it, annoyed AAA games still do.

Avatar image for camachine
camachine

48

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 7

User Lists: 0

Edited By camachine

@naryanrobinson I normally wouldn't have, but the amount of griefing in Nether is truly incredible. I've played plenty of online survival games where you could form pacts with people often because cooperation against superior forces was rewarding (DayZ, Rust, even The Stomping Land). After 30 hours in Nether, I've noticed that people would value killing others for the person's gear, even when cooperation is shoved in their faces.


I see a review as something I'd write for a person who wants to know everything about a game. And when interactions with other almost always guarantees loss of life, accumulated gear, and level (the latter two could have taken hours to gain), it can get immensely frustrating to the point where you no longer care. This was predominant in my experience, and I felt justified in sharing my thoughts.

Avatar image for Divisionbell
Divisionbell

352

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 2

User Lists: 0

It's absolutely accurate too. After many hours of essentially repeating the process of starting over the game is immensely frustrating and really wasn't worth the effort.

Avatar image for DuaMn
DuaMn

146

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 13

User Lists: 0

Edited By DuaMn

@naryanrobinson It's true you can't fault game for what people do, but good games make people want to cooperate when it's needed. It might point to problems with game design, so it's a fair point in my opinion.

Avatar image for Damnation_6
Damnation_6

2197

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 6

User Lists: 0

Bit of a shame, wanted the game to succeed.

Avatar image for loafofgame
loafofgame

1742

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Sigh, this game just makes me want a new S.T.A.L.K.E.R. That game was also buggy, but somehow it was great...

Avatar image for john_matrix_007
John_Matrix_007

160

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 2

User Lists: 5

This is currently selling at 80% off in the Steam Summer sale. Too bad there's no single-player mode, otherwise I might have been interested at that price.

Avatar image for hoyholyhoy
hoyholyhoy

493

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 20

User Lists: 0

Edited By hoyholyhoy

@john_matrix_007 Get The Forest

Avatar image for dannydopamine8
DannyDopamine8

33

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 5

even warz is much higher quality than this game

Avatar image for derikgw
derikgw

30

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 10

User Lists: 5

Edited By derikgw

@dannydopamine8 I don't like this game at all but...seriously? WarZ was like something a 12 year old put together using a unity tutorial. C'mon man!

Avatar image for jinzo9988
jinzo9988

1949

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

@dannydopamine8 I wouldn't go -that- far, but they also took the low road by taking it off of early access before it's ready, and just in time for the sale. They apparently also added crates that you have to pay money to unlock. Greed swallows another one.

Nether More Info

Follow
  • First Released Jun 5, 2014
    released
    • PC
    Nether is an online survival-horror game where you are thrust into a decimated, postapocalyptic city where the remaining human population has degenerated into a chaotic state of lawlessness.
    5.6
    Average Rating25 Rating(s)
    Please Sign In to rate Nether
    Developed by:
    Phosphor Games Studio, LLC
    Published by:
    Nether Productions
    Genre(s):
    MMO, Role-Playing
    Theme(s):
    Sci-Fi