Review

MLB The Show 17 Review

  • First Released Mar 28, 2017
    released
  • PS4

Swinging for the fences.

Hitting a baseball might be the hardest thing to do in professional sports. It's a feat not just reliant on athletic ability, but on skill, patience, and finely tuned mechanics. MLB The Show 17 revels in this fact, making each line drive and moonshot feel immanently special. From the emphatic crack of the bat as the ball is sent careening through the air, to the way the crowd rises to their feet with oohs and aahs in equal parts awe and rabid excitement.

Batting in Sony's long-running series has never been better. Previously, the series' ball physics were modelled on a baseball hitting a flat surface, which resulted in the ball taking relatively straight flight paths with minimal spin. I never considered this to be a facet of the game in urgent need of improvement, but now that the physics are based on the trajectory of a ball colliding off of a round bat, the leap in quality is unmistakable. Not only does this enhancement inject a dose of added realism, but it also increases the variety of dynamic hits you're likely to see. You'll witness balls sliced down the third base line that spin just enough to stay fair, bloops that fall between the second basemen and right fielder, and topspin line drives that soar over the center fielder's head before crashing into an outfield wall. I can't count the amount of times I've paused the game after a scorching double, just to hop into a replay and savour the ball's flight path. The physics are really that good.

No Caption Provided
Gallery image 1Gallery image 2Gallery image 3Gallery image 4Gallery image 5Gallery image 6Gallery image 7Gallery image 8Gallery image 9Gallery image 10

This isn't to suggest fielders are outmatched, however--far from it. Those patrolling the diamond are more intelligent than ever thanks to The Show 17's Humanity AI. You'll never have to worry about a runner being called safe because your shortstop took his sweet time throwing to first base. Now the AI is smart enough to discern between a speed merchant like Billy Hamilton bursting down the line and the lumbering stride of someone like Miguel Cabrera, and can adapt their level of urgency appropriately. They're going to rush throws for those bang-bang plays at first, and take their time when they know they can; banishing the frustration inherent in the lackadaisical fielding that plagued previous entries in the series, while still maintaining The Show's authenticity. A deluge of fluid, new animations tie all of this together. And while the excellent pitching mechanics remain seemingly unchanged, I do appreciate the visible torque apparent in the game's pitching animations. It's a small detail, but one that edges the presentation closer to reality.

Unfortunately, intelligence inside the dugout aren't quite matched by the brains out on the field. AI Managers still aren't great at handling their pitching staff. I've encountered a few instances where relievers have been left to the wolves, long after they should have been pulled from the mound. The most egregious of these occurred when a reliever was summoned into the game, only to give up 11 earned runs on an unbelievable 136 pitches, before his skipper finally decided he had seen enough. I just felt sorry for the poor guy.

The immensely popular career mode Road to the Show returns and is as engrossing as ever. You can still import a character from last year's game to continue where you left off, or start from scratch to guide a young upstart from the fairgrounds of the minor leagues to the 30,000 capacity ballparks on the big stage. In an attempt to breathe some fresh air into the mode, Sony have incorporated a narrative overlay in this year's game, dubbed "Pave Your Path." It's not as substantial or captivating as the story modes found in the NBA2K series or FIFA 17's "The Journey," but it does add some flavour to what was previously a fairly by-the-numbers affair.

Told in a documentary style--think HBO's Hard Knocks--with each scene described by a narrator, you can choose from a range of dialogue options in various baseball-related situations. It's not a robust system, essentially boiling down to whether you want to be humble or arrogant, and do what you think is best for the team or yourself. There are potential repercussions if you continue to disrespect your organisation and its staff, as you're liable to find yourself on the trading block. But the vast majority of interactions offer little more than an opportunity to role-play and shape the personality of your created player, and it doesn't take long before scenes begin to repeat either.

There are a few big moments sprinkled throughout that have more far-reaching consequences, such as interacting with your new team's owner after the draft, or being asked to play another position. I decided to create a shortstop in my career, and after a measly showing in the draft showcase, I was picked in one of the latter rounds by the Milwaukee Brewers. After crushing it for the first couple of months, my Double-A manager invited me into his office and asked if I wanted to try playing third base for ten games or so. I would get a chance to gain some valuable experience in a new position, and if it worked out, my versatility would give the team more options going forward. So I agreed.

Once those ten games had passed, I was called back into the manager's office and informed that the team wanted to keep me at third base for the foreseeable future. I had played exceptionally good defence in the hot corner, and with Jonathan Villar fully entrenched at shortstop on the major league roster, and a top 50 prospect also manning the position in the minors, it made sense that my best path to the majors would go through another position on the field. It doesn't always work this cleanly--with a created pitcher, my demotion to the bullpen was more contrived than believable--but when the stars align and the trajectory of your career naturally deviates, it makes "Pave Your Path" a worthwhile addition to the Road to the Show formula.

Gallery image 1Gallery image 2Gallery image 3Gallery image 4Gallery image 5Gallery image 6Gallery image 7Gallery image 8Gallery image 9Gallery image 10
No Caption Provided

Elsewhere, Franchise has received some time-saving improvements. Traditionally, playing a full 162-game season can be a laborious grind if you're not simply skimming your way through a vast majority of the games. Now there are a few more options on a game-by-game basis if you want to expedite the process and still feel involved. You can still play or manage a full game, or you can cut down the time of games by more than half by selecting quick manage or player lock. The former speeds through games at a rapid pace while still giving you a say in every single at-bat. And, if you want, you can jump in and out at any time and take direct control, even if it's only for one crucial at-bat or two. Meanwhile, player lock lets you play an entire game as a single player, à la Road to the Show. So if you've always just wanted to be Bryce Harper, now you can. These are smart new additions that ensure you can have a palpable impact on all 162-games in a season, no matter how much or how little you actually play.

After card collecting game Diamond Dynasty received a total revamp last year, it returns intact with 30 more legendary players added. So if you've ever wanted to trot out an outfield of Ken Griffey Jr., Ted Williams, and Mike Trout, now you can (provided you're incredibly lucky/willing to spend some cash). And with Griffey emblazoned on the cover, MLB The Show 17 invites some nostalgia with the new Retro mode. With its 8-bit filter and arcade-style one-button mechanics, it invokes old-school classics like R.B.I. Baseball on the NES. It's a fun novelty, but since it's limited to single games, it feels like a missed opportunity without the ability to play a full season.

MLB The Show 17 continues the series' fantastic tradition of consistency and refinement. Improvements to its various game modes give you more ways to play the game how you want to, and the action on the field has never been better, with smarter fielding AI, and enhanced ball physics that bring the hitting to life. Commentary is still a little too stilted for my liking, and there are other blemishes lurking throughout. But when you connect with a fastball and send the ball spiralling into a gap in center field, any issues retreat to the back of your mind. This is America's National Pastime at its best.

Back To Top
The Good
Enhanced ball physics ensure hitting has never been better
Improved fielder AI
More options in Franchise keep you in control without the time investment
When it clicks, "Pave Your Path" enhances the RTTS experience
The Bad
AI managers still have difficulty handling their pitching staff
Retro mode feels like a missed opportunity
Scene repetition is a nuisance in "Pave Your Path"
8
Great
About GameSpot's Reviews

About the Author

Richard divided his time between every mode in MLB The Show 17 over roughly 40 hours of playtime. He will still continue to watch replays of particularly sumptuous hits.
58 Comments  RefreshSorted By 
  • 58 results
  • 1
  • 2
GameSpot has a zero tolerance policy when it comes to toxic conduct in comments. Any abusive, racist, sexist, threatening, bullying, vulgar, and otherwise objectionable behavior will result in moderation and/or account termination. Please keep your discussion civil.

Avatar image for cjtopspin
cjtopspin

Its sad you can't pick what team drafts you. Realistic...but sad. Especially when you get picked by the Marlins.

Avatar image for sonypony4eva
SonyPony4eva

Picked this game up 2 days ago, and is loving every minute of it. I played '14 the entire year nonstop, didn't really like '15 and sold it a month later, and skipped '16 altogether. This will get the same treatment as '14 The Show because I can't stop playing it lol.

Avatar image for agramonte
agramonte

Another top rated game for the ps4... And the only baseball game out there.

Avatar image for deactivated-5a1cc7fd1fbbd

Not much reason to ever buy this even if you're amongst the handful of people that like baseball videogames since this is probably coming as a PS Plus freebie anyways.

Avatar image for Chip1010
Chip1010

@netiger: No version of The Show has ever been a Plus freebie.

Avatar image for deactivated-5a1cc7fd1fbbd

@Chip1010: Nice, maybe they get something that matters to more than 5.000 people then instead.

Avatar image for ButDuuude
ButDuuude

@netiger: stfu

Avatar image for kiloman_74
kiloman_74

@netiger: too late bought it installed it playing it enjoying it! See ya!

Avatar image for naryanrobinson
naryanrobinson

What's an “RTTS experience”?

And you typed “Path your Path” three times.

Does anyone even read these things before they're published? Is twenties too young to reminisce about the good-ol'-days of proofreading?

Online
Avatar image for runstalker
runstalker

@naryanrobinsonIt's totally weird.

He gets the (correct) "Pave Your Path" in paragraph 5, then transforms the next one into "Path Your Path" and tragically compounds the error into oblivion by using "Path Your Path" twice in the review's 'The Good' and 'The Bad' bullet points at the bottom of the article.

I liked the review and sympathize with his eye/brain disconnect (happens), but yeah - proofreading should catch such discrepancies.

Avatar image for runstalker
runstalker

Pretty outstanding selectable options for this if you have the Pro:

- 4K mode = native 4K

- High Detail mode = native 1440p with enhanced lighting, shadows, stadium detail

- High Framerate mode = 1080p full time 60fps

plus HDR for all modes, with a handy slider for HDR intensity.

(Sometimes a slider is better than a curveball. Haha)

Avatar image for dmblum1799
dmblum1799

@runstalker:

Thank, reviews have been neglecting pro features

Avatar image for lastofus234
Lastofus234

@runstalker: can you change that under options ?

Avatar image for runstalker
runstalker

@lastofus234Yeah, in the Audio/Video settings.

Avatar image for lastofus234
Lastofus234

@runstalker: thanks man

Avatar image for sakaixx
sakaiXx

Another great playstation exclusive! This is truly "the greatest lineup" of the year. We dont even need halo or forza or gears 😂😂😂

Avatar image for deactivated-5a1cc7fd1fbbd

@sakaixx: Sounds so true when not being able to play Gears Halo or Forza is the first thing that come to your mind lol.

Avatar image for sakaixx
sakaiXx

@netiger: its called marketing.

Avatar image for RicanV
RicanV

Weird a PS exclusive but I see an 8. Must have spelled 9 wrong.

Moderator
Avatar image for kiloman_74
kiloman_74

@RicanV: cor what's the next big PS4 exclusive that might in for another high score (if it turned out to be really good) farpoint? Wipeout omega? Dragon quest heroes 2? Grand turismio (spelt wrong?)....

Avatar image for VooDooPC
VooDooPC

Can I still give my player the nickname "Franchise Dirtbag"?

Avatar image for domiddian
Domiddian

Baseball isn't even a thing in the UK, it's just seen as a rip-off of Rounders; a sport traditionally played by girls.

However; I would really like to try out an MLB game at some point. Hope they give one away free on PS Plus some day.

Avatar image for cjtopspin
cjtopspin

@domiddian: Well...we also have children playing soccer in the U.S. because it is the easiest game to play. But that is a somewhat limiting statement regarding true skill of someone like Wayne Rooney or Claudio Bravo. Baseball is a game of nuance and total concentration. You have a guy throwing a ball at 156KPH past a guy who has .425 seconds to decide if he wants to swing at the ball or not. The best players in history had success in hitting that ball successfully in 4 out of 10 opportunities. Usually you are considered good if you do it 3 out of 10 times. In essence it is like being a keeper on a penalty....all game long.

Avatar image for ltjohnnyrico
LTJohnnyRico

@domiddian: Genius !! I hated having to play Rounders at School all those years ago !

Avatar image for domiddian
Domiddian

@ltjohnnyrico: That said, I'd still like to play baseball. It's a great sport if you're actually playing it. Watching it on the other hand...

Avatar image for ltjohnnyrico
LTJohnnyRico

@domiddian: I actually went to watch a MLB Game and I had no idea it lasted that long .. was there for hours ! I guess I got my monies worth but there were points where I had no idea what was going on !

Avatar image for ButDuuude
ButDuuude

@domiddian: Never heard of "rounders" in my life.

Avatar image for domiddian
Domiddian

@timthegem: Aww, did my wittle comment trigger you? And resorting to a stereotype? Really? And an outdated one at that? LOL!

Imbecile.

Avatar image for DeviantCode
DeviantCode

Can I play a lefty catcher yet?

Avatar image for yankblan
yankblan

@lonesamurai1: Funny you should say that: http://www.polygon.com/2017/1/27/14414534/mlb-the-show-17-trailer-griffey-motion-capture

Avatar image for dev-raid1
Dev-RAiD1

@lonesamurai1: i cant speak to his swing but hs stance is 100 percent spot on

Avatar image for dev-raid1
Dev-RAiD1

@lonesamurai1: so youve seen his stance look better than him actually doing his stance? lol look out folks we have another delusional pc guy here, and he referenced 2k baseball lmao

Avatar image for dev-raid1
Dev-RAiD1

@lonesamurai1: you are sitting there saying mods on a pc (we know, you lovvvvve pc) are better than the actual person doing their own stance, do you know how insane you sound? griffey is my all time favorite player, its 1 to 1 his stance lmao

Avatar image for kiloman_74
kiloman_74

@lonesamurai1: you still banging on about the retro mode? Concentrate on the main game man! (Game being the appropriate word.....)

Avatar image for kiloman_74
kiloman_74

@lonesamurai1: no no not me! Still, I'm uk based so what do I know anyway! Where or what is the "season mode' in this game?

Avatar image for dev-raid1
Dev-RAiD1

@lonesamurai1: never heard of legends mode, i dont think you have either. you can use them in franchise, DD, which i hate, but i dont think you can in retro. which is a fun mode just gets old quick to someone like me. i dont need the corny music, i dont need ken griffey one liners, make it like baseball superstars or ken griffey for snes, wouldve been gold

Avatar image for louixiii
LouiXIII

Sony's motto this year...8 or better xD

Avatar image for JustPlainLucas
JustPlainLucas

I miss The Show on the Vita... :(

Avatar image for dev-raid1
Dev-RAiD1

@JustPlainLucas: mlb 15 gives the fix i need, i play it at work constantly lol

  • 58 results
  • 1
  • 2

MLB The Show 17 More Info

Follow
  • First Released Mar 28, 2017
    released
    • PlayStation 4
    Retro Mode digs in at the dish for MLB The Show 17 with a no-doubt nostalgic moonshot, atop the expected game modes.
    9
    Average Rating12 Rating(s)
    Please Sign In to rate MLB The Show 17
    Developed by:
    Sony Interactive Entertainment
    Published by:
    Sony Interactive Entertainment
    Genre(s):
    Baseball, Simulation, Sports, Team-Based
    Content is generally suitable for all ages. May contain minimal cartoon, fantasy or mild violence and/or infrequent use of mild language.
    Everyone
    No Descriptors