Review

Dark Souls 2: Crown of the Old Iron King Review

  • First Released Mar 11, 2014
    released
  • Reviewed Aug 27, 2014
  • PS3
  • X360

Ashes to clashes.

The worlds of the Souls games have consistently excelled in conveying a sense of history. There's the impression that their castles and other fortifications have changed ownership by various invaders many times over. The kingdom of Drangleic in Dark Souls II not only feels ancient, but haunted as well. In the Crown of the Old Iron King add-on, the ashen bodies that litter the open spaces of Brume Tower effectively echo the flash-heated victims of Pompeii. Merely touching them casts their fragile shapes into the wind, which is inevitable given that they're littered around the game's fields of battle. Dark Souls might be punishing, but it doesn't punish you for disrespecting the departed, not surprising for a series that encourages the player to embrace death.

Whereas the South-American-inspired temple in Sunken King helped give the first DLC an aptly disconnected feel from the main game, there's a sense that Old Iron King is meant as natural extension of Iron Keep. It's as if Brume Tower were the original mine and furnace of Drangleic, and Iron Keep were built as the fancier upgrade. It explains the lack of moving parts in the map's various towers. In a land strewn with large misplaced gears and other clockwork pieces, Brume Tower is both antiquated and charming. It's of little surprise that recovering the towers' keys and switches make up many of this DLC's objectives. These towers, by the way, are impressively intricate and are more involving than Dark Souls II's other vertical areas, like The Pit. Brume Tower feels like a fortification built around its towers as opposed to the other way around.

Unlike the pervasively dark Sunken King DLC, Old Iron King offers sunlight and digital Vitamin D.
Unlike the pervasively dark Sunken King DLC, Old Iron King offers sunlight and digital Vitamin D.

The settings of Crown of the Old Iron King are both fantastical and relatable, but nowhere near practical. Gigantic suits of armor hang inexplicably under elevator platforms, hinting that humans10 times normal size once protected Drangleic. A part of me laughs at the sight of enormous chain link bridges made of actual chains. I nervously get the camera angle just right so I don't fall off and wonder if I'll have to endure combat on these narrowest of bridges. From Software would be cruel enough to subject us to such tribulations. As it turns out, you won't have to fight anyone on these chains, unless you lack foresight and lure an enemy there yourself. At that point, any deaths on the chains are all on you.

No Caption Provided

Explore thoroughly enough and you eventually find Iron Passage. Given its cavernous, yet tight spaces and its deep roster of demons, this optional area is a clear follow-up to the Cave of the Dead from Crown of the Sunken King. These caves would be the most challenging sections of the Lost Crowns trilogy if not for the two helpful phantoms you can summon. This cavernous journey concludes with a duel against a blue variant of the Smelter Demon, further underscoring the uninspired boss designs of these expansions. Same goes for Fume Knight, a mandatory opponent in Brume Tower who dual-wields melee weapons not unlike The Pursuer and Old Dragonslayer.

If you seek variety, look to Old Iron King's lesser foes. Agile assassins exhibit talents with small blades, lightning spells, and short distance teleportation, so killing them feels all the more gratifying. The most frightening group of creatures appears around the DLC's halfway point: portly humanoids that crawl toward you due to their missing legs. They're especially creepy when they charge at you and self-destruct in an explosion of flame. Picture the legless T-800 at the end of The Terminator mixed with the fireballs in the Final Fantasy series.

No Caption Provided

In Iron Keep, there was an odd ease and simplicity in dipping a group of enemies into a lethal pool of lava by the pull of a switch. Similar conveniences appear in this DLC, provided you're able to spot these situational tricks before you fall victim to these traps yourself. Brume Tower is populated with mutants who carry barrels of explosive and flammable liquid. Their bow-legged movement makes them look scarier than they actually are. Their non-hostile behavior should be your first clue of their usefulness. Much like the windmill puzzle in Dark Souls II, this DLC provides its share of "Ah-ha!" moments, which almost always reveal themselves as you continue to explore and take stock of your surroundings.

I've grown to be that person who can stand in an old building and envision the ghosts of those who have roamed its halls. It's an achievement when a digital environment can trigger similar meditations, something that the Souls games have pulled off time and time again. From Software is keenly aware of this, as evidenced by a memorable, and more importantly, playable flashback sequence of Dark Souls II. What is noteworthy about Crown of the Old Iron King is how it conveys a deep sense history without the help of a flashback. Its slumbering defenses await your arrival, just as they have for countless heroes before and for those who'll follow in your footsteps. It's these guardians who act as the connective tissue between past and present, formidable as always.

  • View Comments (0)
    Back To Top
    The Good
    Feels like a natural extension of the main game
    Rich in implied history
    Environments are inspired by reality but still seem otherworldly
    Abundant in challenging and enjoyable combat
    The Bad
    Like the last DLC, more uninspiring bosses
    8
    Great
    About GameSpot's Reviews
    Other Platform Reviews for Dark Souls II

    About the Author

    Having thoroughly played Dark Souls II, Miguel Concepcion felt that Crown of the Old Iron King was a proverbial old pair of shoes, one that he walked in for an additional ten hours. His appreciation for the history of places and objects hits close to his own home, a townhouse built on the former site of a newspaper publisher.

    Other Takes on Dark Souls II

    For this review, Justin spent 25 hours in the game, killed five bosses, reached level 65, and lit too many bonfires.
    Read Review

    Dark Souls II More Info

    Follow
  • First Released Mar 11, 2014
    released
    • PC
    • PlayStation 3
    • + 3 more
    • PlayStation 4
    • Xbox 360
    • Xbox One
    Dark Souls II is a sequel to From Software's critically acclaimed title Dark Souls. The game features a new hero, a fresh storyline, and an "unfamiliar" setting.
    8
    Average Rating1178 Rating(s)
    Please Sign In to rate Dark Souls II
    Developed by:
    From Software, Namco Bandai Games
    Published by:
    Bandai Namco Games, From Software, Namco Bandai Games
    Genre(s):
    Role-Playing, Action
    Content is generally suitable for ages 13 and up. May contain violence, suggestive themes, crude humor, minimal blood, simulated gambling and/or infrequent use of strong language.
    Teen
    Blood and Gore, Mild Language, Partial Nudity, Violence