There are too many flaws for this game to be acceptable.
+ As far as gameplay goes, this is a mishmash of small puzzles that is strung together in a point-and-click style world. As much as I enjoy puzzles, I thought the puzzles had so many problems to them in the game. First of all, pretty much all of the puzzles are really simple and seem insulting. The hard puzzles, on the other hand, are extremely frustrating but not because they are challenging. There are a splattering of puzzles that are just poorly worded with misleading directions or important rules that are omitted. This makes it almost impossible to know what you are supposed to be doing on the puzzle. After attempting countless wrong answers and then finally discovering the correct one you'll be so angry because you would have known how to solve it if the directions were clearer. And considering this entire game revolves around puzzles that have special instructions, you would think that more care would have gone into this. I can't imagine this passing any sort of play testing before being released with as many inconsistencies as it has.
Story/Presentation: 2/5
+ I have mixed reactions with the story. It seemed bipolar and I wasn't sure if this game was supposed to be comical or creepy. Half the game seems silly and funny, but the rest of the time it feels entirely creepy and spooky. I never got a clear identity of how I was supposed to feel and it seemed to me like the developers couldn't decide what they wanted. Also, the entirely was a huge disappointment and I was really upset that they never really concluded everything. It was such a horrible cop-out and seemed like it was just thrown in because everyone was tired of making the game and wanted it to be over.
Graphics: 4/5
+ I can appreciate the fact that Graham Annable provides the drawing and art behind the game. The graphics aren't really too impressive, but for what the type of puzzle game this sets out to be, good graphics aren't entirely necessary. I think the distinct art style of Annable is enough to make the graphics enjoyable.
Value: 2/5
+ The game is short and only lasts a few hours. The problem is that after you've already solved the puzzles there is absolutely nothing left to do in the game. You already know how to solve the puzzles and there are no new ones introduced. That's it. For $10 that's asking a little much, and considering there were plenty of other flaws I felt this game had, I really don't recommend anyone buying this unless it's on sale for dirt cheap and you feel like wasting a few hours of your life.