ok so i want to do the whole RDR story with 1 horse(most-likely impossible but i wanna try my hardest) So ive had my horse pre much from the beginning, before bonnie tole me to get a horse i went and grabbed one and thats the one ive kept. its been shot once and it has been in evry side and main mission o have done. it trusts me fully aswell. And since im an animal person in real life i naturally am one in games too, And this horse has grown on me(i know all horses pre-much act the same but still!) and i got to the taming horses mission where u eventually tame the mustang. So i tamed it and then i had to mount the mustang so i just kept whisitling for my hoarse behind me so he'd follow until i talked to bonnie who said i can keep the horse. I said no and jumped off after she left and whistled, but then it showed my horse was right behind me......My new mustang -.- I searched the whole perimeter for my other horse and he was no where to be found so i made my way back to the ranch and checked my house to see if he was tied up there....Noope. I WAS PISSED. I loaded the gameso my other horse would be back( i would of loaded anyway because my mustang got shot 4 times and didnt die so he was eventually about to drop)and came here. Is there anyway i can KEEP my horse this time possibly both?

I was the first to buy it the store