Halo 4 should have won. Dishonored was great, but no one beats Chief.

Halo 4 definitely deserved it. Well done.

How is Halo 4 not included? I was most concerned about the soundtrack to Halo 4 and it turned out to be the best part of the game! "Arrival" is absolutely amazing. The other tracks are great too. There is no reason the Halo 4 soundtrack shouldn't be on this.