@moesuir: It is strange that the only negative is the frame rate on replays?
Surely for a 8 there would be more wrong than that?
Or if that's the only negative aspect that it would be a higher rating.
A more detailed breakdown of what makes a rating is needed I think.
E.g. gameplay - x/10, visuals, x/10, music, x/10, and so on to give a scientific answer rather then fingers in the air!