@amillionhp But then again, and I know this was not conveyed in the show for obvious reasons, Robb was only 15 (in the books). Still young, and still acting on a young impulse. That's what made the scene so grim for me. That, and the scene was in the point of view of Catelyn in the novel. I know what you're saying about screwing people over and not expecting to get away with it, but for me the real tragedy is that Robb was still too young and naive to really understand that.