I've been playing since the early release was available and love the game. I find that the reviewer's words of praise do not match the crappy number, which I would set at 8 or 9.

The biggest frustration for me has been Lara's inability to make certain jumps reliably (the aiming spot for her thrown climbing-axe-on-a-rope is too small?). The best improvement is the rappelling / swinging jump capability.

The puzzles are great and having to think about how to get out of challenge tombs is a treat!