Lost Odyssey, Viking, Army of Two. They're all great games, and while I'm perfectly fine with whatever score they get from any website, I'm dead tired of the "innovation" reason. The gaming industry has been around for a bit now, eventually every idea of ever is going to be over with and there will be no more innovation. Pretty sure it's tough out there already, but we're backing ourselves into a corner by nailing games for being uninnovated. If a game is good, isn't good. It's not suddenly bad just because it's similar to something we've seen before.
Especially Lost Odyssey. What an amazing title.