[QUOTE="STWELCH"][QUOTE="MetalGear_Ninty"][QUOTE="STWELCH"][QUOTE="MetalGear_Ninty"] I would disagree. You don't need a degree in leprechaunology to dispel the myth of leprechauns. I don't see how an intricate knowledge of Christian theology would be all that helpful.
MetalGear_Ninty
God, leprechauns, same thing, right?
Bad analogy, an analogy that Dawkins is far too fond of.
And no, it wouldn't be amazingly helpful, but it would allow for more serious debate, rather than the broad, crude bashing they love to do.
You didn't say why it was a bad analogy. 9no God and Leprechauns aren't the same thing, but isn't that the whole point of an analogy?)Anyways, probably not Hitchens, but Dawkins and Harris do participate in serious debate, but of course, they don't engage in the over sensitive and politically correct methods that some love.
Because the belief in Leprechauns don't occupy the central belief of billions of people.
Leprechauns are a specific concept, right down to the actions they perform; God is a pretty broad subject.
The abstract nature of the subject of God is something that Leprechauns do not have; leprechauns are immanent within the physical universe, specifically, Ireland.
God, in a rough approximation of religious theology, is supposed to transcend the universe.
Dawkins doesn't dismiss the concept of God. He dismisses certain concepts of God; I doubt he realizes that the other conceptions of God that might be intellectually appealing to him do exist, which is why I would suggest to him reading more theology.
As a concept, God is not entirely transcendant -- just look at Jesus.Anyway, I don't how any of those things requires you to have a heavily studious knowledge of theology.
Anyway, in his book, The God Delusion, he doesn't just look at the Abrahamic concepts of God. I dare say though, that there are so many concepts of God, that it would be virtually impossible to research them all comprehensively.
In regards to Christology, that is more reflective of God's omnipotence: the fact that He can become powerless unto death.
Log in to comment