[QUOTE="smerlus"] no basically i'm using common sense. If there's are two baseball videogames, the one that mimics real life baseball best is the better of the two. There are two videogame RPGs, the ones that mimic real life RPGs is the better of the two. real simple and nothing to do with my personal opinion.smerlus
That is poor logic there. What makes a "real life RPGs"? Freedom of choice, and exploration within the comfines of a rule set.
and it's flawless logic. EVERYTIME avideogame based on real life has been made ithas been rated on how close it comes to capturing the real thing. I don't think a fan of Flight Sims would appreciate it if the B2 he/she was flying was able to crash underwater and navigate underseas just as well as it does in air, I don't think fans of Forza or Gran Turismo would like their cars to control like Saint's Row 2 and have missles on them.
So according to your logic there shouldn't be such a genre as Arcade Racer ? We should call them either fake racers .. or call them a sub-genre of REAL racing but never a genre ?
I know people bash JRPGs a lot but to not even acknowledge them as real RPGs is completely new to me !
Log in to comment