I loved both GTA4 and RDR but lol I'd say GTA5 without hesitation.Its not really a fair question cause even if you can have alot of fun with Gatling guns, cannons, old guns, horses and such how could it beats flying, fast sports cars, and all other modern stuff.A western game as to be limited cause the world was such in these times.I'd rather see both :D

I'd like to see another one but I think like GTA they should change everything if they make a new one.I would like to see one like the movie ``There will be blood`` or something abit earlier with natives trying to scalp you :oops:

I really liked John and really disliked Jack, I really didnt liked anything about him but I was ok with playing him for the last mission.I think it was a good way to end the game since you rarely replay after you did 100% except for starting a new game.It was fun to have a whole new character with its own lines lol.

Was funny to end the mission and start with this dude, I was like nooo ewww lol

I really liked this game, finished the story mode 3 times played hundreds of hours online.I think the story mode is awesome aldo its easy, a bit slow sometimes and I dont like how it takes alot of time to get some guns specially when you replay it.The story is awesome specially for video game standards its a good western story and I'm sure it would have made a good movie/ tv series and it wouldve been way better than lots of stuff they put on tv.

Online mode is ok I like coop missions but free roaming with friends can be fun too and if you like pvp and competition there's alot of it.There's many bugs and issues online tho and from what I've heard the new online modes from the DLC dont get as much players as others aldo it may have changed since they started selling the full game and cheaper packages.

I only bought the 10$ zombie package when it came out cause other DLC were a joke for 10 $.I think it wasnt so bad you still play the same character and aldo its short and a bit limited the zombies are fun to kill and add a big change to the gameplay cause they dont hide and shoot but chase and jump you.Also the new gun that make the zombies explode is so awesome, you cant get tired of it lol

I think overall they did a great job giving us an epic open world western but with a bit less greediness and laziness it could have been better.

I disagree that its repetitive tho, this game is more linear that GTA and yes its often go there and kill those but thats what this game is about lol Its like playing a racing or hockey game and saying its repetitive cause you only do races or play hockey ...

Its not easy to make an online mode for a game like this but I think they did ok overall.Also many issues were solved with patches and few free DLC.I mostly play coop missions and I could write a 20 pages report on all the bugs and issues surrounding these missions so its far from perfect but it works and its fun.

Also there are things that you can't only blame on the game.For example in coop missions, groups can kick you out cause they wanna play together so sometimes you leave free roam for coop missions so you have to go thru a lenghty loading time only to appear in a lobby with 2-3 friends who kicks you out and back to free roam so you get the loading again to get where you dont want to go and then have to go back and go thru the loading time again ... So yeah there's a private mode where those 3 could have gone to play alone so you can say R* thought about this issue but people dont care or know and many people get some kind of pathetic nerd power trip cause they can kick you.So R* could have made a few seconds warning that give you time to leave and go where you want or they could have made it so it kicks you in another coop mission's lobby instead of back to free roam.Its just sad that many of these issues wouldnt be so hard to fix.

BTW they made different types of free roam after awhile.There's 3 of them one where you cant kill or arm other players one where you can with normal, casual or expert aiming and one where you can still kill other players but only with expert aim.Also all the online modes have an expert aiming only version.I disagree that this game should have had only expert aiming cause 1 its not a FPS and thus harder to free aim and 2 a lot of people including me wouldve hated it if it was so.There's a reason why this type of games nearly always have some kind of auto aim and there's a reason why you dont see many people playing in expert mode.Having an auto aim make it possible for noobs, casual or less talented players to have a somehow fair chance against talented players.Beside if its difficulty you like there's alot you can do to make things harder, you can even remove your mini map lol

Yeah in free roam there's regular people but not as much as in story mode and there's is no random events.

I'd like to see one like the movie ``There will be blood`` You could play a big-shot hire thugs build an empire steal lands from peoples.Would be awesome.

Anything except Jack Marston (ewww) ... LOL I'd rather replay John in another period of his life or a remake of revolver