@timmyp1982: Although I haven't played Generations, I have been noticing people acting like it's a hidden gem. Can't say it isn't because like I said 've never touched the game, but yeah I know what you mean.
A Sonic game in an open world similar to Sonic adventure with gameplay similar to one of the original games would be a nice idea, but just not right now. Too many sandbox games already, so if it's gonna happen it should be in about five years time.
The old/new sonic is crap in my opinion. It's like Mario and Metal Mario. Completely pointless gimmick.
Ezioprez9709's comments