I just played it, and it was an amazing experience. I laughed the whole way through, and the plot was the perfect length. EVERY detail was thought through. It is literally like playing through a season of the show (with a single story arc). Why would you want the plot more drawn out or the combat mechanics to be more difficult? It's not skyrim so if you go into it thinking that it is (like the reviewer clearly did), then of course you'll be disappointed ...but the same is true if you go into call of duty thinking that it is mass effect 3.