@fackman1984: I dunno man, Overwatch pushed a new envelope for sure. And this is coming from someone who has to be dragged into playing Overwatch by his friends. I'm not all about multiplayer only but I can recognize a pivotal game when I see one, and in that sense Overwatch > Uncharted 4
@Henninger: That's a tough call for me, they each have some pretty big faults. But I think I'd have to say God of War edges out a bit just because of how stale the mission structure for Red Dead is. But Red Dead is a lovingly crafted game with a lot to it where God of War felt pretty small for an "epic". Like I fought the same fucking troll boss maybe 16 times, and only a few really memorable boss fights outside of those.
DeadlyMustard's comments