The reviewer got this totally wrong, this game is amazing!
You start off two years after the events of the previous games as a different character and you and your friend Hugh go along almost the same pass as the previous games.
It is a really good feature that you can meet people from the older game and see how they're are going now. Over the game you find out that the main characters friends from the previous game have grown up a lot and have jobs with high-importance.
The gameplay is very fun and addictive to play, as it is the same pokemon that we love to play.
The graphics are incredible for an NDS game and it was the first game I have ever said "woah" to.
The sounds are one of the best parts in this game, containing a mix of old sounds from the previous game and new music.
Thank you Game Freak for this amazing game.