Is this even the same game?

User Rating: 6 | Penumbra: Requiem PC
Good:
1.Some of the puzzles are actually interesting, with multiple ways to complete them...Although I'm not sure if they were purposely designed that way.
2.I like the old school "trials" feel to the game.
3.You get to hear from "Red" again! :)

Bad:
1.All puzzles. There is literally no atmosphere except in 1 or 2 levels.
2.Too easy. The only way you can have trouble with any puzzle is if you are trying too hard.
3.Endings don't really make sense. I have a vague idea of what they are trying to tell you, but I can't seem to grasp the whole picture. Are they being really "deep"? Or did they cop out by making the ending only seem "deep"?
4.Collecting the hidden statues for the alternate ending option. Its really not fun scouring every little corner and every top shelf.

Overall:
It was an ok game, I practically got it for free with the collector pack, so I'm ok with it. Feels like an old version of portal really, the IGN review was spot on.