"A definite improvement, EA is making a strong push to reclaim the top hockey game"
While the shot stick controls make the shootout fun for the shooter, it would be nice to have a more intuitive (maybe just ripping off 2k's mechanics) goalie control system. Another area that EA is lacking is in the franchise mode. Personally I just started a franchise and can't give a detailed long-term review I can say that the lack of a fantasy draft is just plain frustrating. EA did this with Madden last year and seems to underestimate the need to have this in a game.
All in all, playing the game for a little over a day, NHL 08 seems like it is only a few steps away from being everything you could ask for in a hockey game, let's hope this improvement continues in the coming years.