For die hard fans of the series only.
Yet there's a certain level of charm and engrossing feeling when you play Myst. You're free to explore everything at your own pace and in your time. The same is for the sequel, now handled by Presto Studio. While not developed Cyan, it still clearly is Myst.
Let's make one thing clear. You need the patience of a saint for this game. Myst 3 is not an accessible title. True, the game plays with the "point and click" but to grasp the complexity of the puzzles with the vaguest of clues can try even the most devout Buddhist. Obviously with something this difficult the sense of accomplishment is understandably great. But is it worth 2 hours of complete frustration and boredom of not knowing what to do or where to go next? You see, the Myst series is one of those series that is for hardcore nerds like myself and no one else. You have to at least played the previous two titles to get an idea on what is going on and what to expect.
The graphics are phenomenal. The art direction is simply outstanding. Any idiot can see that. Though it sticks to the tried and tested pre rendered backgrounds of Myst and Riven, the ability to look around in complete 360 degree motion is an astonishing feat. The music is also brilliant, with powerful orchestral music for important cut scenes and soft ambient music for exploring, it truly is magnificent. I also like how the environmental sounds add to the whole atmosphere and believability of the game. This truly is a brilliant audio/visual package.
The longevity of the game depends solely on how quickly you solve the puzzles, beat the three Ages and the ending you get, which obviously adds to the re playability. Even if you know exactly what you're doing the game is still pretty big, roughly 20 hours+ to complete it once. This is a big game, but can you survive the frustration to reach the end?
You either have to like Myst or hate it. Those who liked Myst will no doubt love and laud Myst 3 Exile. If you like excitement and hand holding adventuring look elsewhere because this is as hardcore as it gets. It won't gain any new fans but old fans are well catered for.