i skipped 12, and still have MLB 11 the show
my main complaints were:
CPU hits corners and gets the calls way too much with relative ease
Its almost impossible to pitch, even with elite pitchers. Seems pitches are too "random", where one pitch the end up here and the next same pitch, will be completely on the other side of the plate. I get that in real life, not everyone hits their spots, but to me it was just too random.
Its impossible to take walks., even if you work the count 3-0, 3-1, the CPU will then instantly hit a corner, then throw a pitch clearly way low and the ump will call you out. Super annoying, i dont know how many times ive looked at replays, where on NO Fu>CKING PLANET would the pitch ever be called a strike
i get that the umps are supposed to be a bit over the place, but still a pitch thrown 6 inches from the dirt should never be called a strike, yet in this game it is