Garbage.

User Rating: 1 | Madden NFL 09 All-Play WII
So here's the deal: I've been playing Madden for years. I don't mind that EA pretty much releases the same game every year, with updated rosters and a few extra bells and whistles. I'm a football junkie who needs his fill.

My problem is with this Wii version. I have been playing Madden for Playstation systems since they first became available. This was my first chance playing it on the Wii. I will never buy another football game on the Wii again. The Wiimote can't seem to differentiate between a lob pass and a bullet, which can cause some problems, especially in things like the Precision Passing drill. Also, to catch a football, you have to bring up the Wiimote and nunchuck together. After not doing it right the first few tries, I actually put the Wiimote and nunchuck IN THE SAME HAND, and was still told that I need to move them upwards AT THE SAME TIME. The Wii is a fun system, but it's apparently clear that of it's many limitations, sports games, particularly football games, may be something that is best left to the big boys. I'm just going to stick with Madden 08 for the PS2 and leave it at that until I can afford a PS3.