Dynamic Duo trophy/achievement

Avatar image for CaptainFlapjack
#1 Posted by CaptainFlapjack (338 posts) -

Need some help here. I solo'd this game and got every other trophy/achievement. Dynamic Duo is the last one, so I figured I can quickly do a level by myself by just plugging in a second controller. Finished the first stage on Free Play, nothing. Do I have to do this on Replay? Thanks.