Very beautiful game, great story, fantastic graphics with very much attention to detail (Played the game right at launch, on PC/Steam, on Normal -and at times Hard- Difficulty; 48 hrs with 79% Field Guide).
Graphics: 10 Beautiful Graphics with perfect cinematics
Atmosphere: 9 - Very immersive, even for a not very die-hard HP fan like myself
Story: 8,5 great main story. Side quest could've been a bit better.
Sound: 9 Beautiful sound effects
Gameplay: 9 great fighting mechanics; fighting never got boring, although there seems to be a difficulty step missing, since the step-up from Normal to Hard is too great.
Setting: 10 nothing short of breath-taking (Hogwarts castle, the Forbidden Forest, everything looks mesmerizing and it is all presented additionally in both warm and cold seasons).
Characters: 9 - The characters were deep and very well done; (Voice)-acting was wonderful. Same goes for the animations
RPG Elements: 6 - There is an issue with the Gear in this game, as you quickly find all needed legendary gear and looting seems to get pointless, especially towards the end of the game, as it only makes you fill up your inventory, which, by the way, is not very big at all. Furthermore, keeping the magical beasts for items doesn't help much, since there is a just a small amount of upgrades needed. It's great to have so many fashion items, if you take the cosmetic side of things into account; as for the enchantment element - you can enchant every one of the total of 6 things that you can wear at once with only one enchantment. You have many, many enchantments, far too many for their small possibility of use.
In the second part of the game you will also have less need for money, so money got pretty useless in the second half of the game.