I played this twice now: one time without the commentary node and the other with the commentary nodes on. It was a good idea, but i recommend playing it without commentary node first, so after when you play with comm enabled you'll know what it's all about. Although the story and graphics were as interesting than in Half-Life 2(graphics were a little better) the game was very short. It took me only 6 straight hours to finish it(6 hours with all the glitches i had at first and with the loading times...). So i can't give it a 10 as i did to Half-Life 2, but the mark I'll give it is decent for it :D
Other Helpful Reviews for Half-Life 2: Episode One
Graphics – While the graphics in this game are pretty much the same as Half-Life 2. Although I did notice that most of the items and things have a little more detail. I couldn’t believe it when I saw a strider for the ... Read Full Review
Episode One is a continuation of the Half-Life 2 story and picks up just where you were so helplessly cut-off at the end of Half-Life 2. Stepping back into the boots of Gordon Freeman has never felt as good as it does in... Read Full Review