Will a 360 mess up a HD TV?

This topic is locked from further discussion.

Avatar image for dysturbed
#1 Posted by dysturbed (609 posts) -

My parents are planning on gettin one because our last tv broke and we need a hd dvd player aswell and i offerd up the idea of the 360 attachment because its cheaper...Now they said no because they heard the 360 messes up or decreases the life of plasma tvs LCD etc. etc. and thats another reason why i wouldnt be able to play games on it. Now while i think there just misinformed im just wondering if anyone has had trouble with their 360 on the HD tv. And proof of this not being true by link or some sort would be great so i could shove it in there face.

Avatar image for capthavic
#2 Posted by capthavic (6478 posts) -

say what? I think your parents were just looking for an excuse not to buy you one.

Avatar image for gatsbythepig
#3 Posted by gatsbythepig (10742 posts) -
There is always a disclaimer in the owner's manual that says it is possible.  It has to do with how brilliant the colors that are produced from the console and the possibility of burn in.  I have hooked up my video game consoles-since the Atari 2600 to all of my TVs and never had a problem.
Avatar image for sk8jim
#4 Posted by sk8jim (1439 posts) -
Not new models but I dont have a link.
Avatar image for tennisacerg
#5 Posted by tennisacerg (1029 posts) -
only if you leave the xbox 360 on at the same screen for a long time; but, no, it wont hurt it while you are playing
Avatar image for gp19
#6 Posted by gp19 (4252 posts) -
I've had a Plasma for over a year now and a 360 for 9 months, it doesn't do any harm.... AT ALL. I consider my tv set to be very good and I haven't had any problems with burnt images, etc. Another important fact to know is that the image quality hasn't decreased... How do I know? A friend bought the same tv 3 weeks ago and the image is the same. Tell your parents having a console connected to the hdtv is the same thing as having a dvd player. The only problem that may occur is that the tv will be used a lot more with the 360 hooked up to it. :)
Avatar image for thenorminator
#7 Posted by thenorminator (702 posts) -

My parents are planning on gettin one because our last tv broke and we need a hd dvd player aswell and i offerd up the idea of the 360 attachment because its cheaper...Now they said no because they heard the 360 messes up or decreases the life of plasma tvs LCD etc. etc. and thats another reason why i wouldnt be able to play games on it. Now while i think there just misinformed im just wondering if anyone has had trouble with their 360 on the HD tv. And proof of this not being true by link or some sort would be great so i could shove it in there face.

dysturbed

HA HA HA!! my mom did that to me when i was a kid back in the atri,sega,NES,SNES days. No my gamer friend the xbox360/PS3 will not hurt any HDTV. the HDTV and the game console are made for each other. just set the bulb settings to "low lamp" that will help.

Avatar image for Funkyhamster
#8 Posted by Funkyhamster (17366 posts) -
Just if you get a plasma TV, and don't prevent it from being burned in properly...
Avatar image for usagi704
#9 Posted by usagi704 (2058 posts) -
Your parents are clearly paranoid and have no reason to be.
Avatar image for BadAndy642
#10 Posted by BadAndy642 (1069 posts) -

CRT, LCD, DLP Projection, and LCD Projection cannot have screen burn.

CRT Projection and Plasma can have screen burn (of course it is only from static images over long periods of time.  I have a CRT Projection TV and I play my 360 on it a good bit with no problems)

Avatar image for BadAndy642
#11 Posted by BadAndy642 (1069 posts) -

Plasma: link

LCD: link

DLP/LCOS/LCD RPTV: link

There is your proof to show them.

Avatar image for CaUs3
#13 Posted by CaUs3 (2903 posts) -

only if you leave the xbox 360 on at the same screen for a long time; but, no, it wont hurt it while you are playingtennisacerg

Yea

Avatar image for dysturbed
#14 Posted by dysturbed (609 posts) -

say what? I think your parents were just looking for an excuse not to buy you one.

capthavic

there not buying me one its for the living room. i cant drop that kinda of money myself i have a cra and it goes into that. We dont have cable so its not like they would be using it that much. So Lcd tvs wont be hurt by the 360 and wont have burn in?

Avatar image for rdo
#15 Posted by rdo (10314 posts) -

My parents are planning on gettin one because our last tv broke and we need a hd dvd player aswell and i offerd up the idea of the 360 attachment because its cheaper...Now they said no because they heard the 360 messes up or decreases the life of plasma tvs LCD etc. etc. and thats another reason why i wouldnt be able to play games on it. Now while i think there just misinformed im just wondering if anyone has had trouble with their 360 on the HD tv. And proof of this not being true by link or some sort would be great so i could shove it in there face.

dysturbed
the only way a 360 will mess up a tv is if you get mad and throw the controler thru the screen.  well maybe you could throw the power brick too.  but still the video signal wont hurt the picture.  the 360 has built in features you can turn on that will dim the picture or even turn the console off after a period of inactivity.  and most tvs have built in protections as well.
Avatar image for ChevelleFan
#16 Posted by ChevelleFan (1783 posts) -
[QUOTE="capthavic"]

say what? I think your parents were just looking for an excuse not to buy you one.

dysturbed

there not buying me one its for the living room. i cant drop that kinda of money myself i have a cra and it goes into that. We dont have cable so its not like they would be using it that much. So Lcd tvs wont be hurt by the 360 and wont have burn in?

No console will hurt or damage any HDTV and that even goes for plasma.  They probably are thinking about the older projection standard definition TVs which could be harmed by a console, but with technology on newer plasma TVs the risk of burn-in is decreased so much that it is almost non-existent. The 360 was made to play on HDTVs like plasmas, LCDs, and DLPs so it will not harm them or decrease their picture quality.  Look at the Best Buy links and show them to your parents. 

Avatar image for kodex1717
#17 Posted by kodex1717 (5925 posts) -

If you leave anything on a Plasma it will burn it in. Buy an LCD tv, it just doesn't happen to them. Plus, I find the colors more brilliant anyways.

EDIT: The 360 isn't the cheapest HD-DVD player. You can get a HD-A2 for $299.99 at www.valueelectronics.com.  It comes with a free HDMI cable too.